Neapolitan Pizza at Home: Dough and Baking in a Home Oven

Reading a Neapolitan pizza from its puffed rim

Lift a pizza just out of the oven and the center bends softly while only the rim is puffed with air. Moisture from the tomatoes remains on the surface, and the charred spots give off the aroma of wheat. Cut it right away and the thin center and thick rim create two different textures in one pizza.

Neapolitan pizza isn't simply dough stretched thin with toppings on it. Don't flatten the rim, don't overload it with tomato and cheese, and hit it with high heat for a short time. That sequence is what gives you both a tender center and a toasty cornicione (rim).

The standard for authentic "Verace Pizza Napoletana" is a wood-fired oven at about 485°C (905°F), with a bake of 60–90 seconds. If your home oven reaches 250–275°C (480–525°F), you won't get the same thing. So we separate the parts of the official standard to protect from the parts to let go of in a home kitchen, and bake four 25–28 cm pizzas. What to protect at home isn't the temperature number; it's the relationship between a thin center, an untouched rim and light toppings.

Fermentation takes time, but the hands-on time isn't long. Mix the dough at midday, and in the evening stretch the dough balls one at a time; each pizza can go to the table as soon as it's baked. Make two Marinara and two Margherita, and you can compare how the dough and tomato differ with and without cheese.

The Neapolitan table, and where a home oven draws the line

When Neapolitans talk about pizza, they talk not only about the dish but about the hands of the person making it. UNESCO inscribed the "Art of the Neapolitan Pizzaiuolo" as a culinary practice made up of four stages, from preparing the dough to baking it in a wood-fired oven. Its description of this culture also includes young pizza makers learning by watching the master's hands in the bottega, and the way it supports exchange across generations and places where people gather.

On the street corners of Naples there is also pizza a portafoglio: a baked pizza folded in four, wrapped in paper and eaten while walking. The Italian national tourism board describes it as folded and served to take away. The pizza eaten with a knife on a plate is not the only face of Naples; carrying a freshly baked pizza in your hand is part of the city's food culture too.

At home, though, you adapt the way you eat and bake to your own kitchen. A home oven or broiler can't fully reproduce the heat of a wood-fired oven, so preheat a stone or steel thoroughly on the upper rack and top only one pizza at a time, right before baking. The dough recipe, too, is not the official professional recipe transferred as is; we've converted it to a hydration and fermentation time that are easy to measure at home.

Marinara and Margherita are not about adding more toppings

Under the AVPN rules, the basics of "Verace Pizza Napoletana" are the Marinara, with garlic and oregano, and the Margherita, with mozzarella and basil. The EU's Traditional Speciality Guaranteed registration also describes a base of tomato, salt, olive oil and dough, combined with garlic and oregano for the Marinara and mozzarella and basil for the Margherita.

We choose these two for the first four pizzas because, with so few toppings, mistakes show. Cook down the tomatoes and the acidity turns heavy; skip draining the mozzarella and the center turns watery. Conversely, if you leave the rim alone, spread the sauce thinly and eat the pizza as soon as it's baked, the core of the dish comes through even with home-oven heat.

Ingredients (four 25–28 cm pizzas)

For the dough, you can use type 00 pizza flour if you have it, but easy-to-find bread flour also works. 00 doesn't mean "a magic flour that always makes a light dough"; it's a label for how finely the flour is milled. Protein content and fermentation tolerance vary by product, so it's perfectly fine to learn the process with bread flour first and compare 00 flours once you've baked a few times.

Separate what to buy locally from what to seek out

Tomatoes, mozzarella, basil and bread flour are fine bought locally on the day, judging their condition. What's worth seeking out is dried oregano, which defines the aroma of the Marinara, and, if you like to grind whole spices in small amounts, a grinder. Neither is guaranteed to improve the flavor just by buying it.

Whole dried oregano is for people who will make Marinara several times, or who use dried herbs in tomato sauces and bean dishes too. Check the size and whether it's whole leaf. On days you only bake Margherita, or if you already have fragrant ground oregano, the dish works without buying more.

If you buy whole oregano and plan to grind black pepper or dried chiles too, a small grinder is an optional extra. A small tabletop size doesn't take up much space and lets you use freshly ground spices in small amounts. If you only use ground oregano, though, you don't need one. Check the capacity, blade material and the size of spices it can handle, and don't force hard spices like nutmeg into it.

Method: handle the dough lightly and bake one pizza at a time

A dough of 375 g water to 600 g flour is a little sticky at first. Rather than firming it up with extra dusting flour, resting it and then smoothing the surface leaves more air in the rim when it bakes. Once the dough is divided into four, keeping the balls you aren't using from drying out is the top priority.

Cooking tips: recover based on the state of the dough and heat

In a home oven, rather than trying to recreate wood-oven temperatures, a setup that doesn't lose heat and working one pizza at a time pay off. Put the stone or steel on the upper rack and preheat for at least 45 minutes after the oven reaches temperature. If you use an upside-down baking sheet, it loses heat more easily than a thick stone, so allow about 2 minutes longer, and if the bottom comes out pale, preheat longer before the next pizza.

Before throwing out failed dough, figure out what's happening

Enjoy home variations, but keep them apart from the Neapolitan name

Limiting the first four pizzas to Marinara and Margherita makes it easier to compare topping amounts and how the dough bakes. After that, enjoy the ones below as "home pizzas that depart from the official basics." Not mixing up the names is the key to taking liberties while respecting the dish's background.

1. Seasonal pizza with mushrooms and greens

Slice 80 g shimeji or button mushrooms and sauté in 1 tsp oil for 2 minutes to cook off their moisture. Raw mushrooms placed straight on top make the center watery, so cool them before combining with 70 g tomato. Add greens after baking to keep their aroma and color. This isn't one of the two Neapolitan basics, but it's a way to bring the season onto a pizza.

2. A pizza with just a little spicy salami

Use 40 g thinly sliced salami, 4–5 slices, placed along with 80 g mozzarella. If it's very fatty, reduce to 30 g and skip the oil. The more toppings you add, the longer it takes to bake, so don't pile them in the center; scatter them around. With salty cured meats, halve the salt added to the tomatoes.

3. Drained eggplant and basil

Cut 1 eggplant into 5 mm slices, sprinkle with 1 g salt and leave for 10 minutes, then pat dry and brush thinly with oil. Cook 1 minute per side under a broiler or in a skillet, cool, and arrange on top of the tomato. Managing the eggplant's moisture and oil in advance keeps the center from getting wet.

4. A cheese-free Marinara with a different aroma

Rather than adding another half clove of garlic, add just 0.5 g more oregano per pizza. Doubling it for a stronger aroma lets the bitterness of the dried herb cover the tomato. Rub whole oregano between your fingers and scatter it just before baking.

5. Toward a white pizza

Skip the tomato and divide 100 g ricotta, 160 g mozzarella and a little black pepper among the four pizzas. If the ricotta is watery, drain it on paper towels for 10 minutes. On a white pizza the browning of the rim stands out, so don't pile toppings in the center, and keep the oil to 3 ml per pizza. This, too, is a home dish separate from the two basics of Pizza Napoletana.

Take it straight to the table, and handle leftovers safely

Official Neapolitan pizza is defined right down to being eaten as soon as it's baked. Folded and eaten before the moisture in the center settles, the springiness of the rim and the acidity of the tomato arrive together. If you eat it folded by hand, like the pizza a portafoglio the Italian tourism board describes, don't fuss over plating; hand out each pizza while it's hot.

At home, you may not be able to bake four at once. If the first pizza waits on a cold plate, the center steams and the rim deflates, so decide who's eating which before baking them in turn. Don't leave leftover pizza at room temperature for long; once it has cooled slightly, divide it into shallow, clean containers and refrigerate. Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare advises dividing leftovers into shallow containers to cool them quickly and reheating them thoroughly to 75°C (167°F) or above.

To eat it the next day, warm a skillet over medium-low heat for 30 seconds, add the pizza, cover, and heat for 2–3 minutes until the bottom recovers. If you want the cheese softer, drop just 1 tsp water down the side of the pan and trap the steam with the lid. A microwave alone tends to toughen the dough, so if you use one, finish by drying the bottom in a skillet or toaster oven. If you have any doubt about the smell, a sticky surface or how it was stored, throw it out rather than deciding by tasting.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it without 00 flour?

Yes. Make it with 600 g bread flour, and don't switch brands partway; that makes it easier to read how the dough changes. If you use 00 flour, don't set the fermentation time by the label alone; adjust based on the volume in the first rise and the spring-back in the second. Absorption and elasticity differ by product, so you can also hold back some water: mix in 350 g first, then add the remaining 25 g according to the dough.

My home oven only goes up to 250°C.

Put a stone or heavy baking sheet on the upper rack and preheat another 45 minutes after the oven reaches the set temperature. At 250°C, check each pizza at 6–8 minutes, and if the center dries before the rim colors, use fewer toppings. Opening the door repeatedly during baking drops the heat, so limit checks to once. There's no need to claim 485°C like a wood oven; judge doneness by the color of the bottom and the softness of the center.

My mozzarella gets watery.

Lay the cut cheese on paper towels for 10 minutes to remove surface water. If it's a very moist fresh type, reduce 80 g to 70 g and reduce the tomato to 60 g per pizza too. Cutting the cheese too finely releases water all at once, so scattering 2–3 cm chunks keeps the center from getting wet.

What if I want to make the dough the day before?

After the 2-hour first rise, divide into 4, put in containers and refrigerate. How fast it proceeds depends on your refrigerator's temperature and the amount of yeast, so the next day take it out to room temperature 4–6 hours before baking and check whether it reaches 1.5 times its volume. Stretched cold, it shrinks easily and the rim puffs less, so judge by the dough's elasticity, not just the time.

I don't have a peel. Is there a substitute?

A thin cutting board or an upside-down flat baking sheet works. The conditions are dusting the surface with a thin layer of bread flour and baking within 1–2 minutes of topping. Parchment paper makes the transfer easier, but follow the product's label for the temperature and time it can withstand. If the dough won't move, pulling it by force crushes even the bubbles in the rim.

The nutrition figures are estimates for the ingredients above divided into four. Sodium and calories vary with the cheese, canned tomatoes and oil you use. Check labels for wheat, dairy, tomato and so on, and if anyone in the family has dietary restrictions, check the ingredients of any substitutes too.

Sources