Cod au Gratin: Newfoundland Baked Cod in Cheese Sauce

Finished cod au gratin in a baking dish with a golden crumb and cheese crust, flaky white cod in creamy sauce and lemon wedges beside it
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Canadian

Newfoundland cod au gratin: cod baked in a lemony cheese sauce under buttered crumbs. How to split the cheese, judge doneness and swap the cheddar.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Cut the cod and lay it in the dish

Raw cod cut into bite-sized pieces and laid in a single layer in a white casserole dish, with a knife and a small bowl of salt
Keep the pieces in one layer so the sauce can reach all of them

Preheat the oven to 375°F (190°C). If your cod was frozen, make sure it is fully thawed, then pat every fillet dry with paper towels. Cut the fillets into bite-sized pieces and arrange them in a single layer in the casserole dish. Sprinkle a pinch of salt over the fish. The pieces should lie flat and close together with no puddle of liquid around them.

STEP22 / 8

Soften the onion

Diced yellow onion softened and translucent in a lightly oiled saucepan, with a wooden spoon
Stop while the onion is clear and pale. Browning would darken the white sauce

Heat 1 tbsp canola oil in a small saucepan over medium heat. Add the diced onion and cook, stirring now and then, for about 5 minutes. The onion is ready when it is soft and translucent.

STEP33 / 8

Make the roux and whisk in the milk

Milk being poured into the butter, flour and onion roux in a saucepan while a whisk stirs the pale sauce
Pour slowly and keep whisking. The sauce should stay smooth, with no lumps

Add 3 tbsp butter to the onion in the same pan and let it melt. Stir in 3 tbsp flour to make a roux with the onion. Pour in the 2 cups milk a little at a time, whisking after each addition before adding more. Keep stirring until the sauce thickens.

Add the milk slowly

Pouring all the milk in at once leaves floury lumps that are hard to whisk out. A thin stream and steady whisking give a smooth sauce that thickens evenly.

STEP44 / 8

Season the sauce and melt in the cheese

Pale thickened sauce in a saucepan being whisked with lemon zest, black pepper, dried oregano and melting Parmesan and cheddar
Flecks of zest, pepper and oregano should be spread all through the sauce

Stir in ½ tsp salt, 1 tbsp lemon zest, ½ tsp black pepper and ½ tsp dried oregano. Add ½ cup Parmesan and ½ cup cheddar. Whisk until both cheeses have melted completely. The sauce is done when it looks glossy and smooth and you can no longer see strands of cheese.

STEP55 / 8

Pour the sauce over the cod

Pale cheese sauce poured from a saucepan over white cod pieces in a ceramic casserole dish
Work the sauce right into the corners of the dish

Pour the hot cheese sauce over the raw cod in the casserole dish. Use a spoon to push it into the gaps and over the edges so every piece is covered. Uncovered pieces dry out in the oven. When you are done you should see a smooth layer of sauce with only the faint shapes of the fish underneath.

STEP66 / 8

Mix the crumbs and top the dish

A hand adding the crumb and cheese topping over cod in pale creamy sauce, with orange cheddar strands in the unbaked topping
Cheese first, crumbs on top, so the crumbs toast and the cheese melts into the sauce below

Melt 2 tbsp butter in the microwave and stir it into 1 cup breadcrumbs until all the crumbs are moistened. Mix in about 1 cup of the remaining Parmesan and cheddar. Scatter the rest of the cheese directly over the sauced cod, then spread the buttered crumbs evenly on top. Finish with a little black pepper and the remaining ½ tsp oregano. The surface should be an even, sandy layer with no bare patches of sauce.

Use the cheese once

After the sauce, you have 2 cups of cheese left in total. About half goes into the crumbs, and whatever is left goes straight on the fish. Measure the crumb portion first so nothing ends up added twice.

STEP77 / 8

Bake until golden and bubbling

The casserole mid-bake in a home oven, with a golden crumb and cheddar topping and sauce bubbling at the rim
Bubbles at the rim mean the sauce is hot right to the edges

Bake for 40 minutes. Look for a golden-brown top with sauce bubbling up around the edges. Push an instant-read thermometer into the thickest piece of cod in the centre of the dish. The fish should reach at least 158°F (70°C). If it has not, return the dish to the oven and check again.

STEP88 / 8

Rest, then serve

A baked cod au gratin with one portion removed, beside a plate of it with boiled potatoes and a lemon wedge
After resting, the cut edge stays creamy and holds its shape

Set the dish on a trivet and let it rest for at least 20 minutes. During that time the sauce settles and thickens, so a spoonful holds together instead of running across the plate. Serve it as it is, or spoon it over potatoes or rice, with lemon wedges on the side.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Cod fillets, boneless and skinless 1½ lb (680 g) The main ingredient. Cut into bite-sized pieces
Salt (for the fish) a pinch Seasons the raw cod
Canola oil 1 tbsp For softening the onion
Yellow onion 1, diced Sweet base of the sauce
Butter (for the sauce) 3 tbsp With the flour, makes the roux
All-purpose flour 3 tbsp Thickens the sauce
Milk 2 cups (480 ml) The body of the sauce
Salt (for the sauce) ½ tsp Seasons the sauce
Lemon zest 1 tbsp Brightens the rich sauce
Black pepper ½ tsp, plus a little for the top Seasoning
Dried oregano (for the sauce) ½ tsp Herb note in the sauce
Dried oregano (for the top) ½ tsp Herb note on the crust
Butter (for the topping) 2 tbsp, melted Crisps and browns the crumbs
Dry breadcrumbs 1 cup (240 ml) The crunchy crust
Grated Parmesan 1 cup (240 ml), divided ½ cup in the sauce, the rest in the crumbs and on top
Grated cheddar 2 cups (480 ml), divided ½ cup in the sauce, 1½ cups in the crumbs and on top
Lemon wedges as needed For serving
0 / 0

The casserole comes out of the oven with the crumbs gone golden and the sauce bubbling up at the corners. Then it has to sit on the counter, steaming and smelling of butter, lemon and toasted cheese, while everyone waits. Once the waiting is over, a spoon goes in and comes up with big white flakes of cod in a thick, creamy sauce under a crisp, cheesy crust. Cod au gratin is a home dish from Newfoundland and Labrador on Canada's Atlantic coast. It tastes mild and rich at once: sweet onion and milk, a sharp edge from cheddar and Parmesan, and lemon zest to lift it.

A Casserole From the Place Where "Fish" Means Cod

In Newfoundland and Labrador, when someone says "fish," they usually mean cod. Cod sits at the centre of the province's food and its history, and it kept that place even after the 1992 cod moratorium. So a casserole built on cod is about as local as a plate gets. You find cod au gratin in restaurants and in home kitchens, all year round, and especially at Christmas, when a dish of it goes on the holiday table next to everything else.

The dish itself is simple. Pieces of cod are covered in a white sauce with cheese, then topped with buttered breadcrumbs and more cheese and baked until browned. Cod, cheese, milk, onion and breadcrumbs are the ingredients that come back in almost every version. Households change the rest. Some keep it plain with a little dried oregano and lemon, as here. Others add garlic, Dijon mustard, tarragon or chives, and lighten the cheese.

Where it was first made and first written down is not settled. A codfish au gratin casserole was already in print in Newfoundland by the late 1950s, and other dates get passed around as well. What is clear is the role it plays: a year-round home dish built on cod, and a holiday dish. It sits with the rest of the country's home cooking on our Canada page.

Where the name comes from

"Au gratin" is a French cooking term for a dish whose surface is browned in the oven, usually under cheese or breadcrumbs. The name tells you how the dish is finished. It does not say where the dish was first made.


Ingredients (serves 4)

All the ingredients for cod au gratin on a wooden counter: cod fillets, onion, butter, flour, milk, lemon, oregano, pepper, salt, breadcrumbs, Parmesan, cheddar, canola oil and a casserole dish
Grate both cheeses before you start so they are ready to split between the sauce and the topping

The cheese gets used twice, so read the split before you start. Half a cup each of Parmesan and cheddar goes into the sauce. From what is left, about 1 cup is mixed into the breadcrumbs and the rest is scattered straight over the fish.

Allergen information

This dish contains fish (cod), milk (milk, butter, Parmesan, cheddar) and wheat (flour, breadcrumbs). Check the labels on breadcrumbs and grated cheese for any other allergens.

Equipment

  • Casserole dish (ovenproof, large enough to hold the cod in a single layer)
  • Cutting board and sharp knife
  • Small saucepan
  • Wooden spoon and whisk
  • Microwave-safe bowl for melting butter
  • Zester or fine grater for the lemon
  • Instant-read thermometer

Choosing and Substituting

Everything here is at a regular supermarket. What makes it taste like Newfoundland is how three things sit together: mild, flaky cod, a milky onion sauce, and a cheese-and-crumb crust. Keep those and the dish keeps its character.

Ingredient What to buy What a swap changes
Cod Fresh or frozen boneless, skinless fillets. Thaw frozen cod completely and pat it dry Wet fish lets water into the sauce and thins it
Cheddar A block you grate yourself, or pre-shredded cheddar A mild melting-cheese blend melts well but tastes softer and less sharp
Parmesan Grated from a wedge, or grated Parmesan from a tub Wedge Parmesan tastes deeper. The tub kind is drier and saltier
Butter Salted or unsalted With salted butter, go lighter on the salt in the sauce
Breadcrumbs Plain dry breadcrumbs Coarser crumbs give a rougher, crunchier top
Lemon A fresh lemon, scrubbed well before zesting Bottled juice does not replace the zest's aroma
Flour All-purpose wheat flour Cornstarch thickens differently and does not make a roux

Salt cod is a different dish. Soaked salt fish has its own texture and saltiness, and this recipe is built for fresh or frozen cod.


Method

The sauce is made while the cod waits raw in the dish, so cut the fish first, then let one small saucepan carry you from onion to roux to cheese sauce. Once the topping is on, the oven does the work for 40 minutes. After that comes the rest, which is part of the recipe. Plan for the 20 minutes of resting before you serve.

Rest before you serve

Served straight from the oven, the sauce is loose and very hot, and it floods the plate. After 20 minutes it sets to a thick cream around the flakes, and the crust stays crisp.

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
Thin, watery sauce around the fish Frozen cod was not fully thawed or was not dried Thaw completely and pat dry before cutting. Rest the baked dish the full 20 minutes
Lumpy sauce Milk went in too fast Whisk hard off the heat. Next time add the milk a little at a time
Dry, tough pieces of cod Some pieces were not covered by sauce Spoon the sauce over every piece before the topping goes on
Pale, soft topping Crumbs were not coated in butter, or the dish came out early Mix the melted butter through all the crumbs and bake until golden
Centre of the fish below 158°F (70°C) Thick pieces or a crowded dish Return to the oven and check again until it reaches temperature
Sauce runs across the plate Served without resting Let it stand at least 20 minutes
Hot dish

The dish and the bubbling sauce are very hot when they come out of the oven. Use oven mitts, put the dish on a trivet, and keep it out of reach of children while it rests.


Serving, Variations and Leftovers

On the table

Cod au gratin is a full main course. Spoon it over boiled potatoes so they soak up the sauce, or over rice, and put lemon wedges out so everyone can squeeze some over their own portion. A squeeze of lemon cuts through the cheese. In Newfoundland it is eaten all year round and especially at Christmas.

Variations

  • Dijon and tarragon. Whisk a little Dijon mustard and tarragon into the sauce. The mustard adds a gentle bite and the tarragon a sweet, aniseed note, and the dish tastes less cheese-forward.
  • Chives on top. Scatter chopped chives over the top. They add fresh green colour and a mild onion flavour against the browned crust.
  • Garlic in the sauce. Cook a little minced garlic with the onion. It makes the sauce deeper and more savoury.
  • Individual dishes. Divide the cod, sauce and topping among small ovenproof dishes. Each person gets a share of the crust. Judge doneness by the golden top, the bubbling edges and the 158°F (70°C) centre.

Leftovers

Cool leftovers, then cover and refrigerate promptly. Reheat only what you will eat, until it is steaming hot all the way through.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use frozen cod?

Yes. Thaw it completely first, then pat every fillet dry with paper towels before cutting. Frozen fish that goes into the dish wet releases water as it bakes and thins the sauce.

Can I make this with salt cod?

Salt cod makes a different dish. It has to be soaked first, and both its saltiness and its texture change the result. Use fresh or thawed frozen cod for this casserole.

How do I know the fish is cooked under all that topping?

Look for a golden top and sauce bubbling at the edges, then check with a thermometer. Push it into the thickest piece of cod near the centre of the dish. It should read at least 158°F (70°C).

Sources