Caribou Stew: Nunavut Caribou Simmered with Barley and Rutabaga

A deep bowl of brown caribou stew with dark cubes of lean meat, barley, carrot, pale yellow rutabaga and onion
Serves
8–10 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Canadian

Caribou stew from Nunavut, simmered with barley, rutabaga and carrot. How to brown the meat, judge the simmer, check 165°F and swap in moose or beef.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 4

Brown the meat and onions

Cubes of dark meat and chopped onion browning in oil in a heavy pot
The brown film on the bottom of the pot is what the water will pick up as flavor

Set the pot over medium-high heat and warm the oil until it shimmers. Add the cubed meat and the chopped onions, and let them sit and sear before you stir. Turn the pieces as they release from the bottom of the pot. Keep going until the meat has deep brown edges and the onions are golden and soft, with a brown film forming on the bottom of the pot.

Give the meat room

If the meat gives off liquid and turns grey instead of browning, the pot is too crowded. Brown it in batches, then put everything back in the pot before moving on.

STEP22 / 4

Add the roots, barley and water, then boil

The pot at a rolling boil with meat, onion, carrot, rutabaga and barley in the broth
At a full boil the barley grains tumble in the broth before you lower the heat

Add the carrots, rutabaga, barley, water, salt and pepper to the pot, plus the chili powder if you are using it. Stir once to lift the browned bits off the bottom. Turn the heat up and bring the pot to a boil. Move on when bubbles break across the whole surface.

STEP33 / 4

Cover and simmer low

A heavy pot with its lid closed over a low flame
Keep the flame low enough that the lid sits still on the rim

Turn the heat down to low and put the lid on. Simmer for 1 to 1½ hours. Lift the lid now and then to stir, so the barley stays off the bottom of the pot. The stew is ready to check when the meat is tender, the barley grains are plump and soft, and a knife slides easily into the carrot and rutabaga.

Watch the barley, not the clock

Barley keeps absorbing water as it cooks. If the broth turns thick and starts catching on the bottom before the meat is tender, stir in a little water and put the lid back on.

STEP44 / 4

Check every piece, then serve

A thermometer probe pushed into the center of a cooked meat cube resting on a spoon above the pot
Hold the piece still on the spoon so the probe tip stays in the center of the meat

Lift a piece of meat onto a spoon above the open pot and push the thermometer probe into its thickest center. Check several pieces, measuring each one separately. Every piece must reach 165°F (74°C). If any piece reads lower, cover the pot, keep simmering on low and measure again. When every piece passes, ladle the stew into bowls and serve it hot with bannock and water.

Cooking temperature and hot steam

Caribou and other deer-family meat must reach 165°F (74°C). Measure at the thickest center of each piece, testing pieces separately. Tilt the lid away from you when you lift it, because the steam from a long simmer is scalding.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Oil 2 tbsp (30 ml) Browns the meat and onions
Caribou stew meat, cubed 3 lb (1.5 kg) The main ingredient: lean, dark and deep in flavor
Onions, chopped 2 Sweetness, browned together with the meat
Carrots, chopped 6 Sweetness and color
Rutabaga, peeled and chopped 1 Earthy-sweet root that holds its shape through the simmer
Barley, pearl or pot 1 cup (250 ml) Thickens the broth and makes the stew filling
Water 6 cups (1.5 L) The cooking liquid
Salt 1 tbsp (15 ml) Seasoning
Pepper 1 tsp (5 ml) Seasoning
Chili powder (optional) 1–2 tbsp Gentle heat, added with the salt and pepper
0 / 0

The first thing you notice is the hiss of dark, lean cubes of caribou and chopped onion hitting hot oil. The kitchen fills with a sweet, meaty smell as the edges brown. Then the carrots, the pale yellow rutabaga, the barley and the water go in. The pot comes to a hard boil, and the lid goes on for a long, quiet simmer. Caribou stew is the meat-and-barley pot of the Canadian North. It tastes of deep, lean meat and sweet roots, and the barley swells until the broth is thick enough to coat a spoon. Bannock goes on the side, and the pot is big enough for the whole table.

A Pot for the Whole Table in the Canadian North

Caribou stew is usually described as an Inuit and Tłı̨chǫ dish, tied to the northern territories of Nunavut and the Northwest Territories. It is cooked for a crowd. The amounts here fill one big lidded pot and serve eight to ten people. The seasoning is spare. Salt and pepper carry it, with chili powder only if you want it, so the meat, roots and grain set the flavor. Barley does two jobs: it thickens the broth as it cooks, and it makes a bowl filling enough to work as a whole meal.

There is no single fixed recipe. Every household makes its own. In Mittimatalik (Pond Inlet), one home version adds a minestrone soup mix along with potatoes and celery. That pot boils for fifteen minutes, then simmers on low until the potatoes are soft. That home cook prefers lean cuts such as the tenderloin. Further east, in Newfoundland and Labrador, the same one-pot stew is made with either caribou or moose. Other versions bring in rosemary, garlic, tomato paste or red wine. The pot below keeps to the plainer northern core: meat, onion, carrot, rutabaga, barley and water.

At the table the stew comes with bannock and water. That sets it apart from Canada's other home stews, such as the Acadian chicken-and-dumpling fricot, where the starch cooks in the pot. Here the bread stays on the side, ready for wiping the bowl. You can find more of the country's dishes in our Canadian recipes.

Tuktu, the word for caribou

In Inuit kitchens caribou is tuktu, so the same pot is often called tuktu stew. Look for both names when you go looking for family versions from the North.


Ingredients (serves 8–10)

Cubed caribou meat, two onions, one rutabaga, six carrots, dry barley, oil, water, salt and pepper laid out on a counter
One whole rutabaga and six whole carrots: the roots should look like a lot next to the meat
Allergen information

Barley contains gluten. If you use chili powder or frozen mixed vegetables, check the labels on those products too.

Equipment

  • A large heavy pot with a tight lid, about 20 cups (5 L)
  • A sharp knife and a cutting board
  • A wooden spoon
  • An instant-read thermometer
  • A ladle

Choosing the Meat, the Root and the Barley

Caribou rarely shows up in ordinary grocery stores, so most cooks outside the North will choose a substitute. Moose is the closest swap, since the same stew is made with either meat. Lean venison is also close because it shares caribou's low fat. Watch the heat with lean venison, because it tightens if the pot boils hard during the simmer. Beef shank or shoulder, cut into cubes, gives a milder, more familiar flavor and leaves more fat in the broth.

Rutabaga is the root to look for. It is the big, waxy, purple-and-yellow globe, usually sold near the turnips. A small white turnip holds more water, breaks down sooner and tastes sharper. A potato makes the broth starchier and loses the rutabaga's earthy sweetness. Both swaps work, but neither tastes the same.

For barley, buy pearl or pot barley. Other kinds, such as waxy or rolled barley, absorb water and break down at a different rate, so the broth will thicken differently. Salt also varies. Fine table salt tastes saltier by the spoon than coarse kosher salt, so with fine salt start with a little less than the full tablespoon and adjust at the end.

Keep the core, let the extras go

Meat, rutabaga, carrot and barley give this stew its northern character, so keep those four. Chili powder and herbs are optional.


Method: Brown, Boil, Simmer, Check

Cut everything before you turn on the stove: cube the meat, and chop the onions, carrots and rutabaga. Browning needs your full attention. After that comes a quick stage of adding the rest and bringing it to a boil. The long simmer is mostly hands-off, apart from a stir now and then. The thermometer check at the end decides when the stew is ready to serve.

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
The meat turns grey and sits in liquid instead of browning The pot is too crowded or not hot enough Brown in batches over medium-high heat and put everything back in the pot before adding the water
The broth is thick and sticks to the bottom The barley has absorbed the water Stir in a little water, scrape the bottom gently, and keep the heat low with the lid on
The meat is still firm after the simmer Lean meat tightens if the pot boils during the simmer Turn the heat down until the surface barely moves, cover, and keep simmering until the meat is tender
One piece reads below 165°F (74°C) Big or dense pieces heat more slowly Cover, keep simmering, and measure each piece again
The root pieces have fallen apart Turnip or potato was used instead of rutabaga Let them thicken the broth, and next time cut them in larger pieces or use rutabaga
The stew tastes flat or too salty Different salts have different strength Adjust with salt a pinch at a time at the end, and with fine salt start lower next time

Serving, Variations and Storage

At the table

Serve the stew in deep bowls, piping hot, with bannock and water. Tear the bannock and use it to wipe up the barley-thick broth at the bottom of the bowl. One pot feeds a full table of eight to ten, which makes it the stew for family gatherings and big cold-weather meals.

Variations

A bowl of the stew made with peas, corn and diced carrot, beside a small dish of chili powder
Frozen peas and corn make the bowl brighter and sweeter than the rutabaga version
  • Frozen mixed vegetables. Leave out the chopped fresh vegetables and add 4 cups of frozen mixed vegetables about 30 minutes before the end of cooking. The peas and corn keep their color and bring a sweeter, lighter bowl, and you skip most of the chopping.
  • Chili powder. Add 1–2 tbsp with the salt and pepper for a gentle warmth and a redder broth. Start with the smaller amount if bannock-dipping children are at the table.
  • Pond Inlet style. Add a minestrone soup mix, potatoes and celery, boil for fifteen minutes, then simmer on low until the potatoes are soft. The potatoes make it heartier and the soup mix adds a vegetable-herb note.
  • Herb and wine versions. Rosemary, garlic, tomato paste or red wine move the stew toward a richer, darker braise and away from the plain northern pot.

Storage

Cooled stew portioned into clear rectangular freezer containers on a counter
Flat, separate portions are easy to take out one meal at a time

Caribou stew freezes well. Let it cool, portion it into freezer containers, cover them and freeze.

Frequently asked questions

Is rutabaga the same as turnip?

They are different vegetables. Rutabaga is the large root with yellow flesh, and a white turnip is smaller, wetter and sharper. Some versions of this same stew list "turnip," and which root those versions mean is not settled. Buy rutabaga for this pot.

Is a whole tablespoon of salt too much?

It seasons a lot of food: a big batch of meat, a cup of barley and six cups of water. The strength depends on the salt you use, because fine table salt is saltier by the spoon than coarse salt. With fine salt, add a little less at the start and taste once the barley is soft.

How big should I cut the vegetables?

Cut the carrots and rutabaga into chunky, bite-size pieces. They need to hold together through more than an hour of simmering and still be easy to eat from a spoon. Chop the onions smaller so they soften and brown along with the meat.

Can I use a pressure cooker or slow cooker?

The timing and cues here are for a heavy lidded pot on the stove over low heat. Whatever pot you use, finish the same way: the meat should be tender, the barley soft, and every piece at 165°F (74°C) in its thickest center.

Sources