Garlic Fingers: Nova Scotia Garlic Butter and Mozzarella Pizza Strips

A round of garlic fingers cut into thin strips, with a small bowl of donair sauce
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Atlantic Canadian

Garlic fingers from Atlantic Canada's pizzerias swap tomato sauce for garlic butter and mozzarella. Bake them on a hot stone, cut strips, and mix donair sauce.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Heat the stone first, then rest the dough

Two dough rounds resting under a loose cloth on an oiled tray
Cover loosely so the rounds have room to spread under the cloth without sticking to it

Set the pizza stone on the lower rack and turn the oven to 500°F (260°C) before you touch the dough. Heat it for at least 30 minutes. When the oven says it has reached temperature, give it about 15 minutes more, because the stone heats more slowly than the air around it. Meanwhile, divide the dough into two equal pieces, shape each into a ball, and set them at least 4 inches (10 cm) apart on an oiled tray. Cover them loosely with plastic wrap or a damp cloth and leave them somewhere warm until the stone has had its full heat.

STEP22 / 6

Mix the garlic butter

Mixing garlic butter in a bowl with one spoon
Soft butter mixes in seconds; cold butter leaves garlic clumps that spread unevenly

Put the butter, minced garlic, 1 tsp parsley and the red pepper flakes, if using, into a small bowl. Mash and stir with a spoon, pressing the butter against the side of the bowl so the garlic gets worked all the way through. If the butter is unsalted, stir in the salt now. Make it now, right before baking, and use it all today. It is ready when it is soft and spreadable and evenly flecked with garlic and green, with no plain yellow streaks.

STEP33 / 6

Grate the cheese

Grating mozzarella on the coarse side of a box grater, with Parmesan already grated beside it
Fluff the mozzarella shreds apart with your fingers so they scatter evenly in the next step

Grate the Parmesan on the fine side of the box grater, if using, and set it aside in a small bowl. Then grate the mozzarella on the coarse side. Toss the two together or keep them in separate bowls, whichever is easier when you top the dough. You're ready when the mozzarella is a loose pile of separate shreds and the Parmesan is fine and sandy.

STEP44 / 6

Shape one round and top it with half

Scattering half the cheese over a round already spread with garlic butter
Sprinkle from above with an open hand so the cheese falls as a thin layer instead of piling up

Dust the counter lightly with flour. Roll or stretch one ball into a 12- to 14-inch (30–36 cm) round and lay it on parchment on a pizza peel or rimless baking sheet. Spread half the garlic butter over it, leaving a ½- to 1-inch border bare. Scatter half the cheese over the butter in one thin, even layer, with no mounds and no tomato sauce. It is ready when the butter shines across the whole centre, the cheese covers it evenly and the bare rim still shows all the way around.

STEP55 / 6

Bake on the stone, then pull the paper

Garlic cheese round baking directly on the stone, cheese melted and spotting gold
With the paper gone, the crust bakes straight on the stone; watch the cheese, not the clock

Slide the round, parchment and all, onto the hot stone on the lower rack. After 5 to 7 minutes, use an oven mitt to pull the parchment out from under the crust so the dough sits directly on the stone. Bake about 5 minutes more. Take it out when the cheese has fully melted and is just starting to brown in spots.

STEP66 / 6

Cut into strips, then bake the second round

Cutting a halved, parsley-topped round into thin parallel strips with a pizza cutter
Press the cutter straight down through the crust in one firm pass for each strip so the cheese doesn't drag

Move the round to a cutting board and scatter a little more parsley over it if you like. Cut it in half, then use the pizza cutter to cut each half into narrow parallel strips. The strips at the edge come out curved and tapered, and that's how they should look. Shape, top and bake the second ball the same way, using the rest of the garlic butter and cheese. You're done when both bowls are empty and the board holds two rounds' worth of strips.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Pizza dough, homemade or store-bought 1¾ lb (800 g) The base, divided into two rounds
Neutral oil as needed Greases the tray the dough rests on
All-purpose flour as needed Dusting the counter for shaping
Butter, salted (spreadable or softened) 2 tbsp (23 g) Base of the garlic butter; if it is unsalted, add up to ¼ tsp salt
Garlic, fresh 6 cloves Minced; the main flavour
Parsley 1 tsp minced, plus a little for garnish Optional; freshness and colour
Red pepper flakes ¼ tsp Optional; gentle heat
Mozzarella 8 oz (225 g) Coarsely grated; the melting cheese
Parmesan 2 tbsp Optional; finely grated, for a sharper savoury note
Condensed milk (donair sauce, optional) 1 can, 13 oz (300 ml) Body and sweetness of the dip
White vinegar (donair sauce) ⅓ cup (85 g) Tang; thickens the milk
Garlic powder (donair sauce) 1 tsp (3 g) Garlic note in the dip
0 / 0

The round comes off the stone with no red on it anywhere. Mozzarella has melted over a layer of garlic butter and is starting to turn gold in spots, with flecks of parsley through it. Then a pizza cutter goes across it in narrow parallel lines, and the round becomes a board of soft strips. The outer strips curve and taper where the crust bends. In Nova Scotia and across Atlantic Canada these are garlic fingers, a fixture on pizzeria menus, and the strips get dragged through a small bowl of sweet, tangy donair sauce. They are rich and salty, with a strong hit of garlic: a pizza crust that tastes like garlic bread.

A pizzeria staple from Canada's east coast

Same dough, no sauce, cut into strips

Look at pizzeria menus in Nova Scotia and the other Atlantic provinces and you'll find garlic fingers listed right next to the pizzas. They use the same dough and come out the same size. The only difference is the topping. Garlic butter goes where the tomato sauce would be, then mozzarella, then parsley. The round is cut into narrow strips instead of wedges. People order it alongside a donair or a pizza, and it is counted among the East Coast classics with the lobster roll and the donair itself.

That makes it different from the garlic bread most people know. Italian-style garlic bread starts with a loaf. Garlic fingers start with a full pizza round of pizza dough that bakes flat and hot on a stone, so the crust browns underneath while the cheese melts on top. Wisconsin has a similar idea under the names cheese fries or pizza fries, but that is a separate dish with its own home. Where garlic fingers were first made, and by whom, is not settled.

Three names on the menu

Depending on the pizzeria, you'll see garlic fingers, garlic cheese fingers or simply "garlies." The "fingers" are the strips, cut long and narrow so each one is easy to pick up and dip.

The sauce on the side

In Nova Scotia, the standard dip is donair sauce: condensed milk, white vinegar and garlic powder stirred together until thick, pale and sweet-sour. It is the sauce that goes with the donair, the spiced meat sandwich Halifax claims as its own. In December 2015, Halifax council split evenly on whether to make the donair the city's official food, and Mayor Mike Savage broke the tie in its favour. Garlic fingers were not part of that vote. On the table, though, they share the donair's sauce, and the cool sweet dip against hot garlic butter is a large part of why people order them.

Garlic fingers belong to the casual, shared end of Canadian cooking. If you are cooking your way across the country, poutine and butter tarts are good next stops.


Ingredients

Ingredients for garlic fingers and the optional donair sauce
Two rounds of dough, one batch of garlic butter, one pile of cheese: each round gets exactly half

This makes two 12- to 14-inch (30–36 cm) rounds. The butter and cheese below cover both rounds together, so each round gets half.

Fresh garlic, minced fine

Use fresh cloves for the butter, not garlic powder. Mince them small so they spread evenly with the butter. Large pieces sit on the dough as hard bits and can scorch before the cheese browns.

Allergen information

Garlic fingers contain milk (butter, mozzarella, Parmesan, and condensed milk in the sauce) and wheat (the dough and dusting flour). Parmesan is often made with animal rennet, so leave it out when you cook for vegetarians.

Equipment

  • Pizza stone
  • Pizza peel or rimless baking sheet
  • Parchment paper
  • Baking tray for resting the dough
  • Plastic wrap or a clean damp cloth
  • Box grater with coarse and fine sides
  • Small bowls and a spoon
  • Cutting board
  • Pizza cutter
  • Covered container for the donair sauce
  • Oven mitts

Choosing and substituting

Store-bought pizza dough works perfectly well. Garlic fingers are a pizzeria dish, and pizzeria-style dough is exactly right. Homemade is also fine if you have a dough you trust.

For the cheese, a block of mozzarella grated on the coarse side of a box grater melts into an even sheet. A bag of shredded mozzarella sold for melting is a fine shortcut and changes very little. Parmesan adds a sharper, saltier edge. Without it, the strips taste milder and more buttery, and that is the version to make for vegetarians.

Salted butter seasons the whole round on its own. With unsalted butter, stir in the salt from the table, up to ¼ tsp, or the strips taste flat next to the sweet dip. Red pepper flakes are optional. Whether they belong on a Nova Scotia round is unclear, so add them only if you want a little warmth.

For the sauce, use condensed milk, not evaporated milk. Evaporated milk is a different product and won't give the same thick, sweet-sour dip. Keep the milk, vinegar and garlic powder in the amounts given. Changing the balance changes how thick the sauce sets and how sharp it tastes.


Method

Start the oven before you do anything else, because the stone needs the longest time of anything in this recipe. The dough rests and the toppings come together during that time, so nothing waits on anything else. Make the donair sauce first so it can chill. Bake one round at a time, then cut it while the second one bakes.

The donair sauce

Pour the condensed milk into a bowl, add the white vinegar and garlic powder, and stir with a spoon. The vinegar thickens the milk almost as soon as it goes in, and the sauce turns pale, glossy and noticeably heavier on the spoon. Stop when it is smooth with no streaks of thin milk. Transfer it to a container, seal it, and refrigerate it until you serve.

Stirring the donair sauce with a single spoon
Add all three ingredients before you start stirring, then stir until the sauce is one even colour
Give the stone its full heat

The extra 15 minutes after the oven reaches temperature is what browns the bottom of the crust. Without it, the cheese is done while the base is still pale and soft.

Pull the parchment halfway

Parchment makes it easy to slide raw dough onto the stone, but it sits between the crust and the heat. Pulling it out partway through lets the crust finish directly on the stone and crisp underneath.

Hot stone and oven

At 500°F (260°C), the stone, rack and oven door burn instantly. Use oven mitts to slide the round in and to pull out the parchment, and set the peel or sheet down on a heatproof surface.

When it goes wrong

What you see Why What to do
The rim is dark or scorched before the cheese browns Garlic butter was spread right to the edge Keep the border bare on the next round
Pale, greasy cheese in the middle with doughy crust under it The cheese was piled up instead of spread thin Scatter it in one even layer from edge to border
The bottom burns before the top is done The stone runs hot in your oven Lower the temperature a little and move the stone up to the middle rack
The bottom is pale and soft The stone didn't get its full preheat Give it the extra time after the oven reaches temperature before the next round goes in
The strips taste flat next to the dip Unsalted butter without the added salt Stir up to ¼ tsp salt into the butter for the second round
The sauce thickens the moment you stir Vinegar thickens condensed milk, and it is meant to Serve it as is; that body is what lets it cling to the strips

Serving and keeping

At the table

Bring garlic fingers out on the board they were cut on and put the donair sauce in the middle. Everyone pulls off a strip and dips it. They make a good side to order with a pizza or a donair, and they work just as well on their own as a shared snack. Serve them hot, while the cheese still stretches.

Variations

  • Different dips. Marinara, ranch, hot sauce or sweet chili sauce all replace the donair sauce. Marinara brings back the tomato the round leaves out. Sweet chili keeps the sweet-sour idea with heat added.
  • Without Parmesan. The strips taste softer and more buttery, and the dish becomes vegetarian.
  • With red pepper flakes. The butter picks up a slow warmth that comes through after each bite of sweet sauce.

Keeping

Mix the garlic butter just before baking and use it the same day. Don't make it ahead, and don't leave it at room temperature. Keep any leftover donair sauce in a sealed container in the refrigerator.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need donair sauce?

No. Garlic fingers have plenty of flavour without any dip, and plenty of people eat them plain. The sauce adds a cool, sweet contrast to the garlic. Any of the dips under Variations works too.

What if I don't have a pizza stone?

Put a baking sheet in the oven to preheat in place of the stone and bake on it the same way. The crust browns less underneath than it does on a stone, so judge doneness by the cheese melting and starting to spot brown.

My oven doesn't reach 500°F. Can I still make these?

Yes. Preheat at your oven's highest setting with the stone or a baking sheet inside, and give it the full preheat. At a lower temperature, go by the cheese, not the clock: take the round out when the cheese has melted and is starting to brown.

Are the red pepper flakes traditional?

Whether red pepper flakes are standard on Nova Scotia garlic fingers is not settled, which is why they're optional. The core of the dish is garlic butter, mozzarella and parsley. Add the flakes if you like a little heat against the sweet dip.

Sources