Thin, loosely separated onion pakora with mint chutney and chai, an Indian snack
Prep25 min
Cook20 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineIndian

Pyaaz Pakora: Indian Onion Fritters for a Rainy Day

How to make India's pyaaz pakora, with the batter held together by the moisture of the onions. Covers a thin batter of besan and rice flour, how the names change by region, substitutes, judging the frying temperature, fixing mistakes, mint chutney, and storing and reheating. Also covers the rainy-day chai tradition, choosing ingredients and telling when they are done.

Total: 45 minLevel: Beginner

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 5

Cut the onion and aromatics

10 min

Prep for pakora: slicing the onion 2–3 mm wide and loosening the layers with the fingers
Slice the onion thin and loosen the overlapping layers

Halve the onion lengthwise, remove the core and slice it 2–3 mm thin. Loosen the cut layers lightly with your fingers, and chop the cilantro, green chile and ginger. If the onion stays thick, the center is slow to cook even after the batter has colored. If too much is paper-thin, it burns easily, so move the knife blade forward at a constant width.

STEP 22 / 5

Salt it to draw out the moisture

10 min

Moisture seeping from salted thin-sliced onion, with the bottom of the bowl damp
Salting the onion releases the moisture that binds the batter

Put the onion, 5 g of salt, cilantro, green chile and ginger in a bowl. Don't squeeze it by hand; turn it from the bottom with your fingertips for 1 minute, and leave at room temperature for 10 minutes. When the surface of the onion looks moist and a few drops of liquid are visible at the bottom of the bowl, move on. If more than 1 tablespoon of liquid collects, don't discard it; use it as is for binding the flour.

STEP 33 / 5

Mix the flour and spices, and add only as much water as needed

5 min

Besan, rice flour and spices clinging to thin-sliced onion, forming rough battered clumps
Don't make the batter a liquid; adjust it to a thickness that coats the onion surface thinly

Add 120 g besan, 20 g rice flour, the ajwain, coarsely crushed coriander seeds, turmeric, chili powder and hing, and coat the onion with the flour. First mix without adding water, and add 5 ml at a time where it is not holding together. The guide is 15–30 ml. Stop at a thickness where no liquid runs when you tilt the bowl, and a pinch picked up with the fingers lifts a clump of onion without it falling apart.

If you added too much water, add 5 g besan and 1 g rice flour and rest for 1 minute. If liquid still collects at the bottom, adding a little more onion pulls the flavor together better than just adding more flour. If it is floury and won't form a clump, add 5 ml of water and turn from the bottom without kneading hard.

STEP 44 / 5

Fry small clumps in medium-hot oil

15 min

Dropping small clumps of onion into the oil and frying them with gaps so they do not touch
Fry without overcrowding the pot so the oil can circulate between the clumps

Put 800 ml of oil in a pot and heat to 170–175°C. If you have no thermometer, drop in just 1 tsp of batter; it should not sink to the bottom, nor leap up suddenly, but rise slowly with fine bubbles. If the oil is too low the batter sinks and turns heavy, and if it is too high the surface darkens before the onion is cooked.

Pinch up a scant tablespoon of batter with the fingers and drop it in the pot, keeping the gaps in the onion. Fry only 4–5 at a time and don't touch them for the first 40 seconds. When the surface has set, turn them over and fry until the whole is golden brown, 2 minutes 30 seconds to 3 minutes 30 seconds. When the sound suddenly quiets, it is a sign that the moisture has gone, but take them out before the color deepens.

STEP 55 / 5

Drain and serve with mint chutney

5 min

Pakora drained on a rack and plated with mint chutney and chai
Fresh pakora served with mint chutney and a hot tea

When you finish frying, turn off the heat and keep an eye on the pot until the bubbles in the oil have completely settled. Move the pakora to a rack and drain for 1–2 minutes, until the surface is dry and no oil drips when you lift one. Blend 20 g mint, 30 g cilantro, the green chile, 15 ml lemon juice, 2 g salt and 30 ml water, and if grains remain, add only 5 ml of water. Serve the chutney while the pakora are hot, with chai or lemon. Fresh-fried, the thin parts of the batter are lightest, and the longer they sit the more they soften from the onion's steam.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Onion 350g (2 medium) Slice 2–3 mm thin. Red or yellow onion both work
Besan (chickpea flour) 120g The main flour. Replacing it with soy flour or wheat flour alone changes the aroma and texture
Rice flour 20g Lightens the batter. If you don't have it, replace with 20 g more besan; the result is a little softer
Green chile 1 (about 8g) 1 shishito pepper, or omit
Cilantro 10g Minced. If you dislike it, replace with the same amount of chives
Ginger 10g Grated. If it is young ginger with a strong bite, use 8 g
Ajwain seeds 2g Cumin seeds, 2 g, also work. The aroma changes
Coriander seeds 2g Crush coarsely. If using powder, 1 g ground coriander
Turmeric 1g For color. If omitting, 0 g
Chili powder 1g Up to 2 g for more heat. Kashmiri chili gives more color
Asafoetida (hing) 0.3g Optional. If not using, 0 g
Salt 5g Add to the onion first. The salt for the chutney is separate
Water 15–30ml Add 5 ml at a time. On days when the onion is very watery, less than 15 ml is fine
Frying oil 800ml 3–4 cm deep in a pot about 20 cm across. It will not all be absorbed
2 / 2

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Mint leaves 20g Remove the stems. Dried mint will not give the same aroma
Cilantro 30g Not mint alone; it is the green base of the aroma
Green chile 1 (about 8g) Replacing with 1 shishito pepper lowers the heat
Lemon juice 15ml Lime juice also works. Different from the round sourness of tamarind
Salt 2g Start small and adjust together with the fried pakora
Water 30ml Start from the minimum that lets it blend smoothly and add more
0 / 0

When raindrops begin to tap lightly on the roof, the sound of oil in the kitchen rises a notch. The edges of the onion come loose, the besan batter clings to the thin folds, and in the fryer only the brown edges color first. Break open a hot pakora and inside the batter the onion has turned sweet and soft.

Pyaaz pakora (Pyaaz Pakora / Pyaz Pakoda) is an Indian snack in which thinly sliced onion is bound with besan (chickpea flour) and spices and deep-fried. It differs in shape and texture from South India's vengaya bajji, where onion rings are wrapped in a smooth batter; here the layers of onion stay loosened and are fried in small clumps.

The first thing to decide in this dish is the amount of water. Rather than making the batter with water, you bind the flour with the liquid that comes out of the salted onions, and the outside stays thin while the gaps between the onions stay light. Too much water makes the batter thick and it soaks up oil after frying, so don't fill the bowl with a liquid batter from the start.

How this recipe turns out

It makes 12–16 small clumps of onion, for 4 servings. About 25 minutes from cutting to frying, and about 20 minutes of frying. If you gather besan, rice flour and ajwain, those three are mainly what is worth seeking out at an Indian grocery or online. The mint chutney served alongside is made simply by chopping the ingredients and blending.

Tea on a rainy day, and onion pakora

A snack table with onion pakora, mint chutney and masala chai by a rainy window
Fresh-fried pakora is enjoyed with chai as a rainy-day snack

Pakora are fried snacks made across India with changing ingredients. Not only onion but also potato, spinach and green chiles go into the batter. The Indian Express describes the habit, in many parts of the north and west, of pairing hot pakora with masala chai in the rainy season. It is not a claim that rain itself has a special effect; rather, it is probably remembered as a seasonal snack because the damp air outdoors, the sound of frying oil, the scent of spices and the crunch of the hot batter gather in the same scene.

In a recipe by a cook who grew up in Maharashtra, onion pakora is called kanda bhajji and is tied to ginger chai on a rainy day. On the other hand, the same dish is not called by exactly the same name everywhere. Using regional names as an entry point for thinking about how the onion is cut, how thick the batter is, which chutney goes alongside and which herbs are used makes it harder to lose sight of the differences between dishes.

When the name changes, the design of the texture changes

Name / region Shape and how it is eaten Judgment for cooking at home
Pyaaz Pakora / Pyaz Pakoda Loosened thin-sliced onion bound with besan and fried as small clumps Use the moisture from the onion and don't make the batter thick. This is the method here
Kanda Bhajji (Maharashtra) One of the names for onion fritters. Paired with chai and chutney Even if you add curry leaves or green chile, keep the clumps small so they cook evenly
Vengaya Pakoda (Tamil Nadu) Used as a regional name for onion pakora; the combination of spices and herbs changes Don't be pulled by the name; decide the relationship between thin-sliced onion and besan first
Vengaya Bajji (South India) A different type, with onion rings coated in a smooth batter If you want ring shapes, use a separate thicker batter rather than the moisture-based batter here
Bhajia (Chhattisgarh) A regional street snack using onion, chile, potato and more Even when you change the filling, judge the thickness of the batter and crowding of the pan by the same standard

For South India's vengaya bajji, it is described as a dish in which onion is cut into 0.2–0.3 cm rings and coated in batter, with a texture different from pakora made with thin-sliced onion. A tourism guide for Chhattisgarh describes bhajia as a regional dish with onion, chile and potato versions, using besan and spices, and eaten with tea or green chutney. Rather than unify the name into one, deciding first whether you want rings or loosened slices is less likely to lead to failure in a home kitchen.

Ingredients: making a batter without too much water

Ingredients for pakora: onion, besan, rice flour, ajwain and green chile on a wooden board
Line up the ingredients that make the batter and aroma by amount

Choose onions whose layers come apart when sliced thin. Red onions bring more color and heat, and yellow onions give a gentler sweetness after frying. Rather than using several small onions, medium onions that can be sliced to the same thickness make it easier to match the salting time and the doneness.

Pakora ingredients

Besan is flour ground from dried chickpeas. The Ministry of Curry recipe also combines besan and rice flour, and uses the water released from the salted onions to bind the batter. When making it with chickpea flour from a store, check that the label says one of "besan," "chickpea flour" or "gram flour." The more finely the pulses are ground, the more easily the flour clings in the gaps between the onions.

If you try besan only once, a small pack of chickpea flour you already have or from a specialty grocery is enough. If you will make samosa, pakora and besan chilla in succession, there is a reason to choose a 1 kg bag. When buying, check that the ingredient is chickpea, the size and the storage method, and if you already have the flour, don't buy it again.

Mint chutney ingredients

Method: use the onion's moisture in the batter

Rather than sinking the cut onion into flour first, draw out the moisture with salt and then coat with flour. The point is to combine the flour before water collects at the bottom of the bowl. Watching the "states" below, you can adjust even when the size of the onion or the season changes the amount of moisture.

Three things to watch to decide when they are done

Breaking open a pakora to compare the thin batter, the sweetly cooked onion and the golden edges
Judge the finish of pakora by the thickness of the batter, the bubbles in the oil and how the onion is cooked

1. The batter should be pinchable, not something that "falls"

If it runs off a spoon, there is too much water. The right amount is when you lift the thin-sliced onion and see a film of flour, and it loosens slowly when you open your fingertips. A thick batter makes the outside hard, but the onion's steam has trouble escaping and the center turns heavy.

2. Bubbles in the oil are strong only just after adding

Right after cold ingredients go in, the bubbles increase. If you put too many in the pot the oil temperature drops, and the pakora touch each other and the batter peels away. Don't use the first round's color and time as the standard; check that the sound of the pot in the second round is the same. Scoop out burnt bits of batter with a skimmer before they stick to the next fry.

3. No white raw core of onion remains in the cross section

Even when the outside has color, if a clump is large the center of the onion stays raw. Break open the first one; if the onion is translucent and soft and there is no raw whiteness of flour, go on to the next batch. If it is raw, lower the heat, make the clumps 20–30% smaller and fry longer.

How to recover from a failure

If the batter is watery, add 5 g besan and 1 g rice flour and let it rest 1 minute. If it has absorbed oil, halve the next batch and add it after the oil temperature comes back. If only the surface is dark, lower the heat and make the clumps smaller. For pakora that have softened after frying, spread them on a rack to cool a little and reheat in a toaster oven just before eating. Reheating does not bring back the lightness of fresh-fried, so fry the portion you serve guests last.

FSSAI (the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India) advises, for fried foods like pakora, not to keep heating oil for a long time, not to reheat or reuse frying oil, and at home to use a smaller pot and reduce the amount needed. Let the oil cool completely before disposing of it, and don't pass it on to another frying. Because chickpea flour, spices and cilantro are used, if you have allergies or ingredients you can't eat, check the labels and substitutions.

Add a small mill only if you use whole spices

Ajwain and coriander seeds can also be crushed coarsely with the flat of a knife or in a mortar. If you use whole spices beyond pakora, a small table mill lets you release the aroma right before frying. Conversely, if you plan to use up powdered spices anyway, there is no need to buy another tool. Choose one only if you can confirm it works with whole spices.

Names that change by region, and how to eat it at home

A comparison of North Indian loosened pakora, Maharashtra-style small clumps and South Indian ring bajji
The way onion is cut and the thickness of the batter change the texture of similar fried snacks

Pakora is a dish where the combination of filling and batter can change. When recreating it at home, choosing a shape to fit the occasion keeps more of the local range than continuing to search for "the one authentic form."

Loosened thin slices go next to the chai

This pyaaz pakora is a form in which the edges of the onion poke out of small clumps. The thin parts of the batter are crisp, and the center keeps the sweetness of the onion. Matching the green scent of mint chutney, the sourness of lemon and sweet milk tea in turn keeps the flavor from getting heavy within one plate.

Cut into rings, it becomes a different bajji

Slice the onion into rings and dip them one by one in batter, and it comes close to South India's vengaya bajji. Rings have a large batter surface and tend to slip out of a mix bound only by the onion's moisture as here, so switch to a separate thicker batter. Not continuing to use the same amount of liquid after changing the cut is the shortest route to recreating the regional difference at home.

Even when changing the filling, keep the pot uncrowded

When switching to potato, green chile or spinach, adjust the batter to the moisture and thickness of the filling. There are dishes, like Chhattisgarh's bhajia, named by their filling, so onion is not the only right answer. However, the more filling you add, the larger each clump tends to be, so at first add only one kind to the 350 g onion formula. If you want green chile as the star, rather than reducing the onion to 200 g and raising the green chile to 4, first keep to 1 and check how the batter holds together.

To link the table with other Indian snacks, samosa lets you compare the texture of the wrapper, and pav bhaji (in Japanese) the combination of a vegetable stew with bread. On a day leaning toward breakfast, you could share the chutney with idli, the steamed fermented batter.

Frequently asked questions

Pakora cross section, besan, mint chutney and a storage container laid out for checking after cooking
Ingredients and the finished dish are laid out so you can check texture, substitutes and storage

If I add almost no water, won't it be floury?

When you salt the onion, the moisture on its surface dampens the flour. Starting with 15 ml of water and adding 5 ml at a time where it falls short makes it easier to find the place between floury and watery. Mixing in the flour right after adding salt can leave the batter unbound, because no water has come out yet.

Can I replace besan with wheat flour?

Wheat flour alone will give you a fried food, but the chickpea aroma and the crumbly batter change. Replacing it with potato starch alone tends to make the batter hard, so the first time use besan, and if you have no rice flour the safe choice is to put just that 20 g into besan. If you can't eat legumes, redesign it as a different fried food before deciding on a substitute.

Can I make it without ajwain?

You can. Replacing 2 g of ajwain with 2 g of cumin seeds changes the earthy aroma to a warm cumin one. If you have neither, use 0 g and keep the ginger, green chile and cilantro. Adding several powdered spices to make up for it hides the sweetness of the onion.

Can I make the batter ahead and fry it the next day?

Water keeps coming out of the onion, so if you leave the batter mixed the flour turns heavy. Keep the cut onion and flour separate, and salt and mix 10–15 minutes before frying. If you have fried pakora left over, let the steam escape on a rack, refrigerate promptly and finish them by the next day. Reheated, the batter tightens a little and has a different texture from fresh-fried.

Will it turn out the same in an air fryer or oven?

You can reduce the oil, but the thin folds and savory flavor from deep frying will not be the same. The Ministry of Curry also treats deep frying, the oven and the air fryer as separate cooking methods. First fry one batch in a small pot, and try the no-oil methods as a choice to enjoy a different texture. If you round the mix thick, the center turns heavy either way.

Sources