Dutchie: Canadian Square Raisin Yeast Doughnut

Square raisin dutchies coated in a thin white glaze
Serves
9 doughnuts
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Canadian

Dutchies are Canada's square raisin yeast doughnuts. Learn the overnight starter dough, the windowpane cue, frying at 360°F and the thin cinnamon glaze.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Mix and knead the first dough

A stand mixer dough hook kneading the first dough
The first dough looks pale tan from the wholegrain flour and the brown sugar

Put the room-temperature buttermilk, starter, light brown sugar, salt, instant yeast, beaten egg and vanilla into the mixer bowl. Add the bread flour, all-purpose flour and whole wheat or spelt flour on top. Fit the dough hook and knead on medium-low speed for 3 to 5 minutes. Hold back the butter and the raisins for now. Move on when no dry flour is left.

STEP22 / 7

Work in the butter and fold in the raisins

A hand folding raisins into the buttery dough
Fold the dough over the raisins instead of kneading them in, so the fruit stays whole

Add the softened butter in two additions, letting the first disappear before adding the second. Knead on medium-low for about 5 minutes, until the dough passes the windowpane test: stretch a small piece between your fingers and it thins out enough for light to show through without tearing. Drain the soaked raisins and pat them dry. Fold them into the dough by hand, a handful at a time. Stop when the raisins are evenly spread and the dough is smooth and supple again.

Gluten first, raisins last

Pass the windowpane test before any raisins go in. If the dough tears, knead a little longer and test again. Folding the fruit in by hand keeps the raisins whole and stops them from smearing through the crumb.

STEP33 / 7

Rise briefly, then chill

Covered container of raisin dough resting on a refrigerator shelf
The lid keeps the surface from drying out during the long cold rest

Shape the dough into a smooth ball and set it in a lightly oiled container. Cover it and leave it at room temperature for 30 to 45 minutes, until it has grown by about one-third. Then put it in the refrigerator for 6 to 24 hours.

STEP44 / 7

Roll and cut into nine squares

A bench scraper cutting rolled raisin dough into a grid
Press the scraper straight down instead of dragging it, so the edges stay sharp

Turn the cold dough out onto a lightly floured counter. Roll it into an 8 × 8-inch (20 cm) square about ½ inch (1.3 cm) thick, squaring the edges as you go. Cut it into a three-by-three grid with a bench scraper to make 9 pieces. Set each piece on its own parchment square on a tray and cover loosely with lightly oiled plastic wrap. The cuts should be clean, with straight sides and raisins showing at the edges.

STEP55 / 7

Proof until puffy

Proofed square doughs on individual parchment under loose plastic wrap
Fully proofed squares look swollen and soft, with the cut lines rounded off

Leave the tray in a warm place for 60 to 90 minutes. The squares are ready when they have nearly doubled and look soft and pillowy, with slightly rounded corners. Toward the end of the proof, pour the oil into the heavy pot. It should be about 3 inches (7.5 cm) deep and fill no more than half the pot. Leave the squares covered until the oil is hot, so their surfaces don't dry out.

STEP66 / 7

Fry two or three at a time

A skimmer lifting a golden square dutchie out of the oil
A well-fried dutchie floats high in the oil and comes out evenly gold on both sides

Heat the oil to 360°F (182°C). Pick up 2 or 3 squares by their paper and lower them into the oil, paper and all. When the paper releases, pull it out with tongs. Fry for about 3 minutes in total, turning once halfway, and keep the oil at about 350°F (177°C) as you go. Lift each doughnut out with the skimmer onto the rack once both sides are an even, deep gold.

Small batches hold the heat

Never fry more than 2 or 3 at once. Each cold square pulls the oil temperature down. Too many at a time makes the doughnuts greasy and pale. Check the thermometer between batches and let the oil come back up before the next ones go in.

STEP77 / 7

Glaze while warm

Dipping a fried dutchie into thin glaze
On a warm doughnut, the thin glaze turns almost clear as it sets

Let the doughnuts cool on the rack for about 5 minutes. Meanwhile, whisk the icing sugar, salt, cinnamon, hot water and vanilla until completely smooth. The glaze is meant to be thin and runny. Dip the top and sides of each doughnut, let the excess drip off, and set it back on the rack. Leave it for about 10 minutes, until the glaze has set into a sheer, dry shell.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Buttermilk, at room temperature 4½ oz (125 g) Tang and a tender crumb
Sourdough starter, 100% hydration, active and at its peak 1¾ oz (50 g) Flavor and extra lift
Light brown sugar 1½ oz (40 g) Sweetness with a hint of molasses
Kosher salt about ⅕ oz (5 g) Seasoning
Instant yeast about ⅕ oz (5 g) The main rise
Whole egg, beaten, at room temperature 1½ oz (40 g) Richness and color
Vanilla extract about ⅕ oz (6 g) Aroma
Whole nutmeg, freshly grated about ⅓ of a nutmeg Fresh, warm spice note
Bread flour 4½ oz (125 g) Structure and chew
All-purpose flour 3¼ oz (90 g) Softness
Whole wheat or spelt flour 1¼ oz (35 g) Nutty, wholesome depth
Unsalted butter, softened 1½ oz (40 g) Richness and a soft crumb
Raisins 4½ oz (125 g) Sweet, chewy bursts
Neutral frying oil, such as canola about 1 quart (about 1 L) Frying
Icing sugar (powdered sugar), for the glaze about 6½ oz (180 g) Body of the glaze
Kosher salt, for the glaze ¼ tsp (1 g) Keeps the glaze from tasting flat
Ground cinnamon, for the glaze ½ tsp Warm spice
Hot water, for the glaze about 1½ oz (45 g) Loosens the glaze
Vanilla extract, for the glaze 1 tsp Aroma
0 / 0

The square goes into the oil on its own sheet of paper. Soon the dough lets go, the paper floats free and the doughnut puffs up and turns gold, with dark raisins showing through the crust. Five minutes off the oil it goes into a thin cinnamon-vanilla glaze that dries to a sheer, crackly shine. A dutchie is a yeast-raised, raisin-studded square doughnut from Canada. It tastes soft and lightly tangy, with sweet bursts of fruit and a glaze that is barely there, and it is meant to be eaten the day it is fried, with a cup of coffee.

A Square Doughnut With a Long Canadian Memory

The dutchie is usually traced to Tim Hortons in the 1960s. When the first shop opened in 1964 it sold two pastries, the dutchie and the apple fritter. The shape set it apart from the start. A 1965 newspaper advertisement in the Lethbridge Herald, placed by Woolworth's Bakery, is the earliest known printed use of the name, and it sold the doughnut on its shape alone.

The name in print

The 1965 advertisement reads "DUTCHIE DONUTS … The New Square Donut." In Canada the word means this square glazed doughnut. It has nothing to do with "dutchie" in Jamaican English, where it means a cooking pot.

Nobody has settled where the name, the square cut or the raisins came from. The author of the home recipe adapted here points to Dutch oliebollen, fried dough balls, as a possible link. It is only a guess.

Gone, missed and brought back

For decades the dutchie sat in the case beside rings and fritters. Then sales fell and it was dropped. Reports disagree on the date: some say 2014, others the early 2000s. It came back briefly in 2017 for Canada's 150th anniversary. In June 2023 the chain asked customers which old favourite should return, and the dutchie led the vote. On January 10, 2024 it went back into stores as part of the chain's 60th-anniversary menu.

The chain has not published its recipe. What follows is a home dutchie with the same features: a soft enriched yeast dough with a little sourdough starter for tang, three flours, plenty of raisins, the square cut and a thin sugar glaze. For more of the country's food, see Canadian recipes.


Ingredients (makes 9)

Dough and glaze ingredients set out in separate plain bowls
Keep the three flours in separate bowls, and set the glaze ingredients apart from the dough ingredients
Weigh, don't scoop

Use a digital scale for everything. Kosher salt crystals differ in size from brand to brand, so a spoonful of one weighs more than a spoonful of another. Grams keep the salt, yeast and starter where they should be.

Allergen information

This dough contains wheat (bread, all-purpose, whole wheat and spelt flour are all wheat), egg, and milk (buttermilk and butter). The glaze contains no allergens beyond those, but it goes onto the same doughnuts.

Equipment

  • Digital kitchen scale
  • Stand mixer with a dough hook
  • Lightly oiled container with a lid
  • Rolling pin
  • Bench scraper
  • Nine 3 × 3-inch (7.6 cm) squares of parchment paper
  • Baking tray and plastic wrap
  • Heavy, deep pot with a deep-fry thermometer, or an electric fryer
  • Wire skimmer and tongs
  • Wire rack set over a tray
  • Shallow bowl and whisk for the glaze

Choosing and Substituting

Most of the list is ordinary supermarket shopping. The sourdough starter is the one item to plan for. It should be a 100% hydration starter, meaning equal weights of flour and water, and it should be at its peak, bubbly and risen. The starter adds the faint tang under the sweetness and helps the yeast. Leaving it out changes how much flour and liquid the dough holds, so this dough is built around it.

Ingredient What to buy If you swap it
Buttermilk Cultured buttermilk from the dairy case A homemade soured-milk stand-in gives less tang and a thinner body
Light brown sugar Light (not dark) brown sugar Darker or less refined sugars push the flavor toward molasses and darken the crumb
Nutmeg A whole nutmeg and a fine grater Ground nutmeg tastes duller and dustier than freshly grated, so add it a little at a time
All-purpose flour Plain all-purpose flour Cake or pastry flour makes a weaker, more cakey dough
Whole wheat or spelt Either works Spelt is milder and sweeter, whole wheat earthier
Frying oil Any neutral oil, such as canola Strongly flavored oils show through the thin glaze

Keep the raisins, the square cut and the thin glaze. Those three make it a dutchie. The exact brown sugar or wholegrain flour matters less.


Method

The dough takes two days, and most of that time is hands-off. On day one, soak the raisins in lukewarm water for at least 15 minutes while you mix, then knead and give the dough a short rise at room temperature. After that it goes into the refrigerator for 6 to 24 hours, so mixing in the evening and frying the next day works well. On frying day, roll, cut and proof the squares. Set up the pot while they rise, then fry and glaze in one go.

Frying oil

Never leave hot oil unattended, and keep children and pets away from the stove. Keep the oil no more than half the depth of the pot. If you use an electric fryer, follow its manual. Lower the dough in gently, away from you, and let the oil cool completely in the pot before you move or discard it.

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
The dough barely grows in the first rise The starter was past its peak, or the room is cool Use a starter that is bubbly and at its peak, and give the dough a warmer spot. Wait for the one-third rise rather than watching the clock
The dough tears in the windowpane test The gluten isn't developed enough yet Knead a few minutes longer on medium-low and test again before adding raisins
The dough turns wet and streaky after the raisins go in The raisins were still wet Drain them well and pat them dry before folding them in
The doughnuts come out greasy and pale Too many in the pot dropped the oil temperature Fry 2 or 3 at a time and let the oil climb back to temperature between batches
The paper stays stuck to the dough It hasn't released yet Leave it. Once the underside sets, the paper lets go on its own and you can lift it out

Serving and Variations

Dutchies are at their best the day they are fried. Put them out on the rack or a plain plate with strong coffee, mid-morning or as an afternoon break. Expect people to pick at the raisins showing at the edges. The thin glaze softens the longer they sit, which is one more reason to fry on the day you plan to eat them.

Variations

  • Spelt instead of whole wheat. The crumb tastes milder and a little sweeter.
  • A thicker glaze. Whisk in less hot water and the glaze sets into a whiter, more opaque coat with more sweetness and crunch. It looks less like a classic dutchie.
  • Freshly grated against ground nutmeg. Fresh nutmeg gives a bright, lifted spice. Ground nutmeg makes a flatter, quieter doughnut that leans more on the cinnamon in the glaze.

Frequently asked questions

Is this the same as the Tim Hortons dutchie?

It is a home version with the same features: square, yeast-raised, full of raisins and thinly glazed. The chain keeps its own recipe private. The starter and the wholegrain flour give this version a little more tang and depth than a plain yeast doughnut.

Can I make it without sourdough starter?

This dough is balanced around the starter, which adds both liquid and flour as well as flavor. Leaving it out means reworking the whole dough, and no starter-free version is given here.

Why does each square sit on its own paper?

A fully proofed square is soft and easy to dent. The paper lets you carry it to the oil and lower it in without touching the dough, so it keeps its puffed shape. Once the dough sets, the paper releases and you lift it out.

How do I fit the long chill into my week?

The cold rest can last anywhere from 6 to 24 hours, which leaves plenty of room. Mix and knead the evening before, chill overnight, and roll, proof and fry the next morning or afternoon. Plan the frying for the day you want to serve them.

Sources