A plate of choila: charred chicken cut into bite-size pieces and tossed with red chili, scallions, and cilantro, served with beaten rice (chiura)
Prep20 min
Cook20 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineNepali

Choila: Newar Grilled Meat with Sizzling Mustard Oil

A recipe for choila, the Newar dish of the Kathmandu Valley in Nepal: smoky grilled chicken thigh tossed with timur (Nepali pepper), cumin, turmeric, and scallions, then finished with hot mustard oil and fenugreek. Its meaning on the festival plate samay baji, how to get a good char, and the heat for the oil pour called jhannu.

Total: 50 minLevel: Beginner

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 6

Grill the chicken until charred

Grilling strips of chicken thigh on a rack until charred
6–7 minutes per side, until reddish brown with black char

Trim excess fat from the chicken thighs, cut into strips about 5 cm wide, and sprinkle with 1/4 teaspoon salt. Heat a grill rack or grill pan over medium heat and cook skin side down first. Grill 6–7 minutes per side, until the whole surface is reddish brown with black char in spots. Insert a thermometer in the thickest part; it is done when the center reaches 75°C or higher and the juices run clear.

STEP 22 / 6

Cool and cut into bite-size pieces

Cutting grilled chicken thigh into 2 cm bite-size cubes on a cutting board
Rest about 10 minutes, then cut into 2 cm cubes

Move the grilled chicken to a tray, cover loosely with aluminum foil, and let it rest about 10 minutes so the heat carries through and settles. When cool enough to touch, cut into 2 cm bite-size cubes. Cutting right out of the grill lets the clear juices run out, so resting it a little is the key.

STEP 33 / 6

Combine the aromatics and spices

Mixing chopped red onion, scallions, cilantro, and spices in a heatproof bowl
Stir about 30 seconds, until the spices coat the vegetables

In a large heatproof bowl, put the chopped red onion, sliced scallions, chopped cilantro, grated garlic and ginger, chili flakes, ground cumin, timur, turmeric, and 1 teaspoon salt, and stir with a spoon for about 30 seconds. It is enough when the spices coat all the vegetables and the turmeric tints everything faintly yellow.

STEP 44 / 6

Add the chicken and toss

Tossing bite-size chicken with aromatics and spices in a bowl
Toss about 1 minute, until the spices coat the meat evenly

Add the 2 cm cubes of chicken to the bowl and toss with a spoon or clean hands for about 1 minute, until the aromatics and spices coat the surface of the meat evenly. Choila is a dry dish, so look for spices clinging to the meat. At this point taste a piece, and if it needs salt, add a pinch.

STEP 55 / 6

Heat the mustard oil and fry the fenugreek

Heating mustard oil in a small pan and frying fenugreek seeds and garlic
Turn off the heat when the seeds are dark brown and the garlic lightly colored

Put 2 tablespoons of mustard oil in a small pan and heat over medium heat for 1–2 minutes. When the surface of the oil starts to shimmer and a faint smoke rises, add 1/2 teaspoon fenugreek seeds. In 20–30 seconds the seeds turn dark brown and the aroma rises; add 1 clove of chopped garlic, and when it takes on a light color in about 10 seconds, turn off the heat right away. Fenugreek turns harshly bitter if burned black, so stop at dark brown.

STEP 66 / 6

Pour on the hot oil and finish with lime

Pouring hot mustard oil over the chicken and aromatics and squeezing lime
Pour on the hot oil, mix, and finish with lime juice

As soon as you turn off the heat, pour the hot oil, fenugreek and garlic included, over the chicken in the bowl. Confirm the sizzle and the rising aroma, then mix for about 30 seconds to spread the oil through. Add the lime juice, mix once more, and serve on a plate with the tomato. Put the chiura alongside and eat while warm or after it settles to room temperature.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 4

The grilled meat

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Chicken thigh 500 g Skin on. The original recipe uses gammon (cured pork)
Salt (for seasoning) 1/4 tsp Sprinkle on before grilling
2 / 4

Aromatics and spices for tossing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Red onion 1 Finely chopped
Scallions 1 bunch (about 100 g) Sliced thin
Cilantro 1 bunch (about 20 g) Finely chopped
Garlic (grated) 1 tbsp —
Ginger (grated) 1 tbsp —
Coarse chili flakes 1 tbsp Use half if you do not like heat
Ground cumin 1 tsp —
Timur (Nepali pepper, ground) 1 tsp Ground Sichuan pepper can substitute
Turmeric 1/2 tsp —
Salt 1 tsp Taste and adjust
Lime juice 1 lime Lemon juice also works
3 / 4

Finishing oil (jhannu)

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Mustard oil 2 tbsp Edible kind
Fenugreek seeds 1/2 tsp —
Garlic 1 clove Finely chopped
4 / 4

To serve

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beaten rice (chiura) 160 g (40 g for 1 person) White rice or bread also works
Tomato 1 Cut in wedges. For garnish
0 / 0

Drop fenugreek seeds into mustard oil warmed in a small pan. They crackle and turn dark brown, and when a bitter-sweet aroma rises, add a pinch of chopped garlic. Then pour that hot oil in one sweep over the grilled meat and aromatics waiting in a bowl, and with a sizzle the smell of chili and pepper spreads all at once. This is choila, the grilled-meat salad that the Newar people of the Kathmandu Valley never leave out, on festival days or on nights drinking with friends.

The plate of fire: grilled meat at the heart of Newar festivals

The festival plate samay baji in the Kathmandu Valley, with choila, beaten rice, boiled egg, and greens

The Newars are the people who have lived in the Kathmandu Valley from the start, in Kathmandu, Patan (Lalitpur), Bhaktapur, Kirtipur, and elsewhere. In the Newar language choila is written छ्वय्‌ला. Traditionally it was made with water buffalo meat, seared over a fire of rice straw. The smoky char from the straw fire is the foundation of the dish's flavor. Two kinds were made at home: "haku choila" (haku means black in Newar), made by grilling, and "mana choila," made by boiling seasoned meat.

Choila is the dish placed at the center of the Newar festival assortment called "samay baji." The plate holds beaten rice (baji), the local spirit aila, greens, boiled egg, and more, and each is said to stand for one of five elements. Choila stands for fire, and it is treated as connected to Agni, which means life force and vitality.

Did you know

Before the festival of Dashain, at the full moon of the month of Ashwin (mid-September to mid-October), there is a custom of making water buffalo choila, preparing samay baji, and setting five pieces outside the house as an offering to the gods. In some families, the feast on the eighth day of Dashain puts 12 vegetable dishes and 12 pieces of choila on a banana leaf, and the number of dishes varies by family and region.

Cooking over gas flame is now normal, and chicken or mushrooms are often used in place of buffalo. What has not changed is the oil. Newar cooks say that "choila is made only with mustard oil." Grilled meat is tossed with aromatics and spices, and at the end hot oil is poured over to bring out the fragrance. In Nepali this finishing step is called jhannu.


Ingredient notes for the home cook

Mustard oil, fenugreek seeds, Sichuan pepper, turmeric, ground cumin, scallions, and red onion

The proportions in this article are based on a recipe contributed to the official website of the UK's Chevening Scholarships by Sushmit Sharma Bhattarai, a Chevening scholar from Nepal. He could not find water buffalo meat in the UK and made it with gammon, a cured pork product. Here it is replaced with chicken thigh, which is easy to find and also widely used in Nepal.

One key to the flavor is timur, Nepal's pepper. It has a citrusy, tongue-numbing aroma and can be found at Nepali grocery stores. If you cannot find it, Chinese Sichuan pepper can stand in. The aroma is a little different, but the numbing sensation is very similar. For mustard oil, look for a bottle labeled as edible at Indian or Nepali grocery stores or online.

Tip

Holding the chicken directly over a gas flame on a grill rack gets you closer to the traditional smokiness of straw-fire grilling. If you do not have a rack, use a grill pan or broiler and cook until the surface is well browned. If the char is pale, the dish will lack smokiness when tossed.

The beaten rice served with choila (chiura, called baji in Newar) is rice that has been steamed, flattened, and dried, and is available at Nepali grocery stores. Its crisp bite is just right for alternating with the spicy meat. If you cannot find it, it is also good with plain white rice or bread.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Ingredients for choila: chicken thigh, red onion, scallions, cilantro, garlic, ginger, chili, spices, mustard oil, and lime

Allergy and food-safety notes

Mustard oil is pressed from mustard seeds, a plant of the same Brassicaceae family as mustard. When pouring hot oil over the ingredients it can splatter, so use a heatproof bowl and keep your face back. The amount of chili flakes and timur greatly changes the heat, so if children will eat it, use half or less.


How to make choila

Including the time to grill and cool the chicken, allow about 50 minutes in all. Chop the aromatics while the grilled meat cools and it comes together quickly.

Food-safety note

Cook the chicken all the way through. To prevent Campylobacter food poisoning, Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare urges cooking chicken to 75°C at the center for at least 1 minute. Do not judge by the surface char alone; check the thickest part.

Tip

If the hot oil does not sizzle on the ingredients, it is not hot enough. Put it back on the heat just before pouring, and pour when the fenugreek and garlic are making fine bubbles, for a strong aroma.

With chiura, as a snack or a meal

A Newar spread: choila, beaten rice, boiled egg, and stir-fried greens on a metal plate
Alternate the toasty chiura with the spicy grilled meat

Choila is good piping hot, but it has a different appeal after it settles to room temperature. As the meat cools, the hot oil and spices soak into the surface and the flavors marry. Take a pinch of chiura, then a piece of choila. The crisp bite and mild sweetness of the beaten rice soften the heat of the chili and timur.

At a Newar feast, choila is set out with local spirits, boiled egg, greens, and bean dishes, and everyone picks at them together. At home, put it beside the Newar spiced meat pukala (in Japanese) and the Nepali steamed dumplings momo, and the table looks like a set of small plates at a Nepali eatery. For an everyday meal, it also makes one of the side dishes of dal bhat.

Did you know

Choila is also an offering to Newar deities, including the household guardian deity, ancestral gods, and gods such as Bhairav and Durga. When it is made as an offering, the custom is to make it without tomato. At Indrayani Jatra, the festival in Kirtipur, choila is also considered an essential dish.

Ways to vary it

Choila made with roasted mushrooms, topped with crushed peanuts

For a meatless version there is mushroom choila. Halve about 20 mushrooms, heat 2 tablespoons of mustard oil in a skillet, and cook slowly over low heat. When browned, toss them with the aromatics and spices as you would the chicken. Scattering dry-toasted, crushed peanuts on top adds a crunchy texture.

For even more smokiness without a grill rack, you can also quickly sear the surface of the grilled chicken with a kitchen torch. Made with sliced pork shoulder or beef instead of chicken, it gets a chew closer to water buffalo meat. You can adjust the heat with timur and chili, so find the amount you like from the second time on.

Frequently asked questions

Choila in a storage container, refrigerated

What if I do not have mustard oil?

You can make it with vegetable oil, but you will not get the sharp aroma of mustard oil that Newar cooks insist on. The impression of the aroma changes a great deal, so prepare mustard oil if you can.

Can I make it ahead?

Once tossed, let the choila cool a little, put it in a storage container, refrigerate, and finish it by the next day. Moisture comes out of the onion and cilantro, so the aroma is weaker than freshly made. Bringing it back to room temperature before eating helps the aroma return.

Are timur and Sichuan pepper the same?

Both are the fruit of plants in the genus Zanthoxylum of the citrus family, and both have a tongue-numbing aroma. Timur is the one used in Nepal, with a stronger, fresh citrusy fragrance. Substituting Sichuan pepper gives a similar numbness but a slightly heavier aroma.

I do not have a grill rack. Can I make it in a skillet?

Yes. Heat a skillet well over medium heat, and without oil start skin side down, blotting up the fat that comes out with paper towels, and cook until both sides are browned. It chars less easily than a rack, so be sure to pat the surface of the chicken dry before cooking.

Sources