Taiwanese red-braised beef noodle soup: thick noodles, cubed beef shank, bok choy, and scallions in a deep reddish-brown broth
Prep20 min
Cook2 hr 30 min
Serves4 servings
CuisineTaiwanese

Taiwanese Beef Noodle Soup: Red-Braised with Doubanjiang and Star Anise

A recipe for hong shao beef noodle soup, Taiwan's signature noodle dish, braised for 2 hours with beef shank, doubanjiang, star anise, and soy sauce. The theories of its origin in the military villages of Gangshan, Kaohsiung, the three styles (red-braised, clear-simmered, tomato), the heat that keeps the beef tender, and pairing with noodles and bok choy.

Total: 2 hr 50 minLevel: Intermediate

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP 11 / 7

Parboil the beef

A pot of parboiled beef shank with scum floating
Boil for 5 minutes, and when scum has risen, drain in a colander and wash under running water

Put the beef shank cut into 4 cm cubes, 3 slices of ginger, and 2.4 L of water in a large pot and set over high heat. Once it boils, boil hard for 5 minutes, and when a lot of gray scum has risen to the surface, drain in a colander. Wash the beef well under running water to remove the scum clinging to the surface. This parboiling makes a clear broth, so do not skip it even though it is a nuisance. Wash the pot as well.

STEP 22 / 7

Dry-toast the spices

Star anise, cinnamon, bay leaves, and coriander seeds being dry-toasted in a pot
Take them out when the aroma rises and the star anise has deepened slightly in color

Set a heavy pot over medium heat and, without oil, toast the star anise, bay leaves, coriander seeds, and cinnamon stick for 1 to 2 minutes, shaking the pot. Take them out when the aroma rises and the star anise has deepened slightly in color. If they burn they turn bitter, so take the pot off the heat before smoke rises. Put the star anise and coriander seeds in a spice bag and tie it shut, and set the bay leaves and cinnamon aside.

STEP 33 / 7

Sauté the aromatics and tomatoes

Tomatoes, onion, scallions, and garlic being sautéed in the pot
Sauté until the tomatoes and onion have softened a little

Turn the same pot to slightly above medium heat and add 2 tbsp vegetable oil. Add the tomatoes, onion, garlic, ginger, the white parts of the scallions, and the dried red chiles, sprinkle with a pinch of salt, and sauté for about 3 minutes. Move on when the corners of the tomatoes have rounded and the edges of the onion have turned a little translucent. You do not need to brown anything here.

STEP 44 / 7

Add the doubanjiang and beef

Parboiled beef added to the pot with sautéed doubanjiang and tomato paste
When the oil has turned red, add the beef and coat it all over with the seasonings

Over medium heat, add 1 tbsp doubanjiang, 1 tbsp tomato paste, and 1 tbsp rock sugar, and mix all through, pressing against the bottom of the pot. When the oil has turned red and the toasty aroma of the doubanjiang rises, add the parboiled beef and stir together for about 2 minutes. It is enough when the seasonings evenly coat the surface of the beef. Doubanjiang scorches easily, so if the bottom of the pot starts to blacken, lower the heat a little.

STEP 55 / 7

Braise for 2 hours

Beef noodle broth braising quietly over low heat with the lid on
Do not boil it hard; keep the heat so the surface only now and then trembles

Add the spice bag, bay leaves, cinnamon stick, 120 ml Shaoxing wine, 60 ml soy sauce, and 3 tbsp dark soy sauce, and pour in water to about 2.5 cm above the ingredients (a guide is 1.2 to 1.4 L). Bring to a boil over high heat, skim the scum that rises, and then lower to low heat. Cover and braise for about 2 hours at a quiet heat where the surface only now and then trembles. If it keeps boiling hard, the meat tightens and turns tough, and the broth clouds. It is done when the beef splits easily when pressed with chopsticks.

STEP 66 / 7

Adjust the broth

Spices taken out of the finished broth and the broth being tasted
Take out the spices and season a bit strongly, on the assumption it will go over noodles

When the braise is done, turn the heat to low and take about 5 minutes to adjust the final seasoning. First take out the spice bag, cinnamon stick, and bay leaves. If a lot of fat floats on the surface, skim it lightly with a ladle. Take a small amount of broth and taste it; if it lacks salt, add salt, and if the color or sweetness is lacking, add dark soy sauce 1 tsp at a time. Poured over noodles it will taste diluted, so the right saltiness is when the broth tastes a little strong on its own.

STEP 77 / 7

Boil the noodles and bok choy and assemble

Boiled noodles and bok choy in a bowl with beef and broth poured over
Boil the noodles and bok choy in the same water, then finish by pouring on the beef and broth

Bring plenty of water to a boil in another pot, add the Chinese noodles and bok choy together, and boil for about 4 minutes, or as directed on the noodle package. When the noodles have loosened and the stems of the bok choy are bright green, drain well in a colander. Divide the noodles and bok choy among bowls and pour in plenty of beef and hot broth. Scatter the reserved scallion greens, and add chile oil to taste and pickled mustard greens chopped to about 5 mm.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 4

Parboiling the beef

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef shank 1.3 kg Cut into 4 cm cubes. Chuck or short rib also work
Ginger (for parboiling) 3 slices Thinly sliced
Water (for parboiling) 2.4 L Enough to cover the beef well
2 / 4

Aromatic spices

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Star anise 2 pods Put in a spice bag
Coriander seeds 1 tsp Put in a spice bag
Bay leaves 2 Go straight into the pot
Cinnamon stick 1 Cassia is the traditional form. Ceylon cinnamon also works
3 / 4

Braising ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Tomatoes 2 large Cut into 8 wedges
Onion 1 Cut into 2.5 cm squares
Garlic 6 cloves Crushed with the flat of a knife
Ginger 3 slices Thinly sliced
Scallions 6 Cut the white parts into 5 cm lengths, and slice the green parts thinly and set aside
Dried red chiles 2 Increase or decrease the heat to taste
Doubanjiang (chile bean paste) 1 tbsp An ordinary store-bought one works
Tomato paste 1 tbsp —
Rock sugar 1 tbsp Brown sugar or raw cane sugar also works
Shaoxing wine 120 ml Taiwanese cooking rice wine gives a lighter-colored broth
Soy sauce 60 ml Regular (dark) soy sauce
Dark soy sauce (lao chou) 3 tbsp For color and body. Taste at the end and add more if needed
Water 1.2–1.4 L To about 2.5 cm above the ingredients
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp —
Salt A little Adjust to taste at the end
4 / 4

Finishing

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Chinese wheat noodles 4 portions Thick fresh noodles suit it. If dried, enough for 4 servings
Bok choy 450 g Trim the base evenly
Green parts of scallions The portion set aside Thinly sliced
Chile oil A little Optional
Pickled mustard greens (takana-style) 4 tbsp Chopped. Stands in for Taiwanese suan cai. Optional
0 / 0

Through the steam, the shop owner ladles reddish-brown broth from a big pot and heaps cubed beef on the noodles. In an alley in Taipei or beside a market in Kaohsiung, there is a shop at lunchtime with a line of people holding bowls. Hong shao beef noodle soup (紅燒牛肉麵, hóngshāo niúròu miàn) is noodles in a broth of beef braised with soy sauce, doubanjiang, and star anise, one of the most beloved noodle dishes in Taiwan.

A bowl born in the military villages

The storefront of a small beef noodle shop in an alley of an old military village in Kaohsiung

The history of beef noodle soup overlaps with Taiwan's postwar history. Around 1949, many soldiers and their families crossed from the mainland to Taiwan with the Nationalists, who had lost the Chinese Civil War. The settlements where these military families lived are called "juancun" (眷村, military dependents' villages). Encyclopedic explanations in English say that Sichuan-born veterans who settled in Kaohsiung began selling it in the military villages, and that this was the start of Taiwanese beef noodle soup.

Some accounts name a more specific place. A 2018 Taipei Times article introduces the view that Gangshan in Kaohsiung may be the real hometown of beef noodle soup. The person who spread this idea was the essayist Lu Yaodong, who lived long in Taipei. He thought "Sichuan-style" beef noodle soup was a dish born in Taiwan and might have originated in the military villages of Gangshan. The evidence he cited was Gangshan's spicy doubanjiang. This doubanjiang was made and sold by a man named Liu Mingde, who came from the mainland in 1948, and was not an old local product. However, this is one leading theory, and the origin has not been firmly established.

A bit of trivia

In Taiwan some shops call beef noodle soup "Sichuan beef noodle soup," but because Sichuan Province has a separate beef noodle dish of its own, imagining the authentic place from the name alone causes confusion. Taiwan's hong shao beef noodle soup is best appreciated as a dish that grew up in Taiwan.

In Taiwan, cattle were originally important workers for plowing fields, and there were not a few people who avoided eating beef. For that reason, those who ate beef noodle soup at first are said to have been mainly people who came from the mainland. In time, this bowl spread through the cities and changed the habit of eating beef itself. Today Taipei holds a beef noodle festival every year where cooks compete, and it has become a national dish.


Three styles: red-braised, clear-simmered, and tomato

Three beef noodle soups side by side: soy-colored red-braised, clear-simmered, and red tomato

Taiwanese beef noodle soup falls roughly into three styles. The best known is hong shao (紅燒, red-braised), simmered with soy sauce and doubanjiang. The broth is reddish brown, sweet-spicy, and rich. Qing dun (清燉, clear-simmered) is a clear broth without soy sauce, scented with Sichuan peppercorn and white pepper, putting the flavor of the beef itself in front. Fan qie (番茄, tomato) is a sour broth with simmered tomatoes. This recipe makes the red-braised style, but it also uses a little tomato. The acidity of the tomato tightens the sweetness of the soy sauce so the broth does not become too heavy.

The usual toppings are chopped pickled mustard greens (suan cai) and scallions. At the shop counter, small dishes of simmered dried tofu and seaweed are lined up, and you pick what you like to eat with your bowl. At home, even just having pickled mustard greens ready brings the mood of a Taiwanese eatery much closer.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Beef shank, doubanjiang, star anise, cinnamon, tomatoes, scallions, soy sauce, and Chinese noodles

Tip

Dark soy sauce is a kind of Chinese soy sauce that is deeply colored with a thick, syrupy sweetness. The deep reddish-brown color of the broth is decided by this one bottle, so getting it from an Asian grocery or online changes the result. If you cannot find it, you can make the dish with a little more regular soy sauce, but the color of the broth will be lighter.

Tip

The more sinew beef shank has, the more meltingly tender it becomes when simmered for a long time. Buying it in a whole piece and cutting it into 4 cm cubes yourself gives you a size that is uniform and resists falling apart.


How to make Taiwanese beef noodle soup

Prep takes about 20 minutes, cooking including the braise about 2 hours 30 minutes, and the whole about 2 hours 50 minutes. The 2 hours of braising is nearly hands-off, so prepare the noodles and greens in the meantime.

Caution

Parboiling and braising involve handling a large amount of boiling water. Hold the pot with both hands, and when draining into a colander, pour it in the sink, turned so that steam does not hit your face. When sautéing the doubanjiang the oil splatters easily, so keep your hands away.

Tip

If the broth reduces during the braise and the beef shows above the surface, add boiling water until the ingredients are covered again. Adding cold water stops the simmer and takes time to come back up to temperature.

Serving and how it is eaten in Taiwan

A finished bowl of hong shao beef noodle soup with bok choy, scallions, and pickled mustard greens
Lay the beef on the noodles and add scallions and pickled mustard greens

In Taiwanese shops, you first slurp the noodles, bite into the beef in between, and add suan cai partway through to change the flavor as you go. When the sourness and saltiness of the pickled greens come in, the rich broth suddenly lightens. Changing the flavor midway with the condiments on the table is also part of the enjoyment of beef noodle soup. A few drops of chile oil bring up aroma and heat.

There are dishes pairing beef and noodles in the same bowl in northwest China as well. Compared with Shaanxi's biangbiang noodles, wide hand-pulled noodles dressed with chile and hot oil, you see how much the Taiwanese bowl is a soup dish even though both use wheat noodles. To add one more dish of a Taiwanese eatery, lu rou fan, sweet-savory braised pork over rice, is also recommended.

Variations and making ahead

Beef noodle broth divided into storage containers and stored separately from the beef

With a pressure cooker, the braising time can be shortened considerably. Some English-language recipes put similar ingredients in a pressure cooker and cook at high pressure for 40 minutes. In that case, use a little less water in step 5, and after pressure cooking, taste the broth and adjust with water.

If you want less heat, leave out the red chiles and reduce the doubanjiang to 2 tsp. If you want it hotter, use more chile oil at the finish. If you make the broth ahead, on a weeknight you only need to boil noodles to have a Taiwanese bowl. Let the broth and beef cool a little before refrigerating, and removing the fat that has set white on the surface before reheating gives a cleaner taste.

Frequently asked questions

Seasonings for Taiwanese beef noodle soup: doubanjiang, dark soy sauce, and star anise

Is store-bought doubanjiang fine?

Yes. An ordinary Sichuan-style doubanjiang is enough to make it delicious. The saltiness and heat differ by product, so start with just 1 tbsp and adjust with soy sauce and salt at the final tasting.

Can I make it with cuts other than beef shank?

Chuck and short rib also work. They are fattier than shank, so skimming a bit more of the fat floating on the broth at the end keeps it from being heavy.

What if I do not have Shaoxing wine?

Sake can substitute. You lose the aged aroma of Shaoxing wine, but the broth turns out lighter in taste. If you do not want to use alcohol, replace it with the same amount of water and adjust with soy sauce.

How long can I keep it?

Refrigerate it as soon as it has cooled a little and finish it soon. When reheating, heat it in a pot until the whole thing is thoroughly boiling. Boiling the noodles just before eating keeps them from getting soggy and tastes best.

Sources