Cabrito Stoba: Aruban Goat Stew with Tomato and Potato

Aruban cabrito stoba: goat, salt beef and potatoes in an orange-red tomato stew
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Aruban

Cabrito stoba is Aruba's goat stew with salt beef, tomato and potato. Learn to turn salt beef into stock, brown the goat, and judge when the meat is tender.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Soak and simmer the salt beef

STEP 1

Cover the salt beef with water and leave it in the refrigerator overnight. Drain it, put it in the pot with 4 cups of fresh water and bring it to a boil. Lower the heat, cover, and simmer for 1 hour. It is ready when a fork slides into the beef easily.

STEP22 / 7

Cube the beef and strain the stock

Cubed cooked salt beef beside a bowl of strained stock
The cooked salt beef should pull into fibers at the cut edge, and the strained stock should run clear

Lift the beef out of the pot and cut it into small cubes. Set the cubes aside. Pour the cooking liquid through a fine strainer into a bowl and keep it for the end of the recipe. You have firm, fibrous beef cubes and a pale, clear stock.

STEP33 / 7

Brown the goat

Goat cubes browning in vegetable oil in a heavy pot
A thin film of oil should stay on the pot bottom while the goat browns; if it dries out the meat sticks and scorches

Set the same pot back on the heat with 3 tbsp vegetable oil. When the oil shimmers, add the goat cubes and spread them out so they sizzle instead of steaming. Turn them as they color. Move on when the outsides are deep brown all over.

Brown hard, then simmer

Leave the cubes alone long enough to take color before you turn them. That brown crust flavors the tomato gravy later. Stand back from the pot, because the hot oil spits when the meat goes in.

STEP44 / 7

Soften the aromatics

Onion, garlic, green pepper and habanero frying with the browned goat
The pot should still look like a fry-up here, with oil visible and no liquid pooling yet

Add the onion, garlic, green pepper and habanero to the browned goat. Stir them through the oil and scrape up the brown bits on the bottom of the pot. Cook for about 3–4 minutes. They are done when the onion has wilted and turned soft and glossy.

STEP55 / 7

Simmer with tomato and seasonings

Goat, salt beef and aromatics simmering in reddish-orange tomato
Small, lazy bubbles are the right pace; a hard boil splatters the tomato and catches on the bottom

Add the tomatoes, sugar, lime juice, nutmeg, annatto oil and the reserved salt-beef cubes. Stir everything together and bring it to a gentle simmer. Simmer for 20 minutes. The tomatoes break down into a thick, reddish-orange gravy that bubbles slowly around the meat.

STEP66 / 7

Add the stock and potatoes

Potato chunks simmering in the orange-red stew
As the potatoes soften, their edges round off and the broth thickens slightly

Pour in the reserved stock and add the potato cubes. Bring the pot to a boil, then lower the heat. Simmer for 30 minutes. It is ready when a knife slides into a potato cube with no resistance.

STEP77 / 7

Check the goat and season

STEP 7

Fish out a piece of goat and press it with a fork. If it still resists, keep the pot at a low simmer and check again until it is tender. Taste the broth, and add salt only if the salt beef has left it short. The stew is done when the goat pulls apart under a fork and the potatoes are soft.

Tenderness decides when it is done

Goat varies by cut and by the age of the animal, so the clock gives you checkpoints and the fork gives you the answer. If the potatoes soften before the goat does, lower the heat and keep simmering until the meat gives way.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Salt beef 6 oz Soaked overnight, then simmered; seasons the stew and makes the stock
Water 4 cups For simmering the salt beef; becomes the stock
Vegetable oil 3 tbsp For browning the goat
Goat (or lamb), cut into ½-inch cubes 2 lb The main meat
Onion, diced 2 cups Sweet aromatic base
Garlic, minced 2 cloves Aromatic
Green bell pepper, seeded and chopped 1 medium Fresh, green flavor
Habanero chile, seeded and minced 1 Heat
Tomatoes, peeled and diced 2 cups Body of the gravy
Potatoes, peeled, cut into 1-inch cubes 3 Bulk; thickens the broth as they soften
Sugar 1 tsp Rounds out the tomato
Fresh lime juice 1 tbsp Brightness
Ground nutmeg ¼ tsp Warm spice
Annatto oil (achiote oil) 2 tsp Orange-red color and earthy aroma
Annatto seeds (achiote) ½ tsp Kept alongside the annatto oil; not added separately in the steps
Salt To taste Only if the stock needs it
0 / 0

Watch the pot when the peeled tomatoes go in. The goat is already browned, and the onion has slumped into the oil with the green pepper and the habanero. Then the annatto oil goes in and the whole pot turns a deep orange-red, sharpened by lime and warmed by a pinch of nutmeg. Cabrito stoba is the goat stew of Aruba. Small cubes of goat and salt beef cook down in tomato, and the stock from the salt beef and chunks of potato go in at the end. It eats hearty and savory, with the salt beef seasoning the broth and the chile heat building slowly under the sweetness of the tomato.

Goat Stew in the Shade of the Kwihi Tree

Goats roam free on Aruba and its neighbors Bonaire and Curaçao, and goat meat sits in ordinary Aruban supermarkets, so a goat stew there is a household dish. Goat stew is a tradition on Aruba, and it is popular on the other two islands too. In plantation days, the midday meal often meant a stew of beef, goat or fish. Workers ate it in the shade of the kwihi tree.

A chef at Aruba's Gasparito restaurant describes what goat brings to a stew this way: goat is hearty, and it gives more broth than beef does, which is why this pot ends up generous with gravy for spooning over a starch. In Aruban restaurants the stew arrives with funchi, the island's cornmeal polenta, and with banana hasa, fried plantain. At home it goes just as happily with rice or more potatoes.

The pot changes from kitchen to kitchen. One Aruban version uses young kid instead of grown goat. It enriches the stew with butter and ruku and adds concomber, the spiny pale-green cucumber that belongs in the traditional cooks' version. Restaurant kitchens cooking by the ten-pound batch thicken theirs with tomato paste and ketchup and season it with curry and paprika. The recipe here is neither of those. It is a home pot of goat and salt beef in tomato and annatto oil, with potatoes to finish.

The name

You will see it written both ways, stoba di cabrito and cabrito stoba. Stoba is the stew and cabrito is the goat. The same name turns up on Bonaire and Curaçao, but each island's pot has its own recipe. This one is the Aruban version.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Ingredients for cabrito stoba: goat, salt beef, vegetables, seasonings and annatto seeds
The salt beef is soaked before anything else; the cut vegetables can wait in their bowls until the goat is browned
Handling the habanero

Wear gloves to seed and mince the habanero, and keep your hands away from your eyes and face until the gloves are off. Wash the knife and board before they touch anything else.

Equipment

  • Heavy pot or Dutch oven with a lid
  • Fine strainer and a bowl for the stock
  • Cutting board and sharp knife
  • Kitchen gloves for the chile
  • Wooden spoon
  • Meat thermometer

Choosing and Substituting

Goat is the one ingredient worth a special trip. Look for frozen cubed goat at a specialty butcher or order it online. Good goat is red and has little smell. Lamb is the accepted stand-in and goes in at the same point.

Salt beef is the next hunt. It does two jobs here: it seasons the meat in the pot, and its cooking water becomes the stock. Corned beef is a different product, with a different texture and saltiness, so if you use it, the stock comes out differently and you taste before adding any salt. Leaving the salt beef out makes the stew lighter in both salt and savor.

Annatto oil and seeds are sold online. Paprika can stand in for the color but not for the earthy annatto flavor. If you cannot find a habanero, use another fresh chile, and the heat changes with whatever you choose. The concomber of the old kid version is hard to find outside the islands, and this pot leaves it out.

The salt beef sets the seasoning

Give the salt beef its full overnight soak in the refrigerator. The soak draws out salt, so it affects how salty the stock turns out, and the stock goes into the whole stew.


Method

Start the night before by soaking the salt beef. On cooking day, the salt beef simmers for an hour while you dice the onion, mince the garlic and chile, chop the pepper and peel the tomatoes and potatoes. After that the work happens in the same pot, and the last two simmers are mostly hands-off time.

Cooking goat safely

Cook the goat until it is tender all the way through. Goat counts with beef and lamb, and whole cuts are safe at 145°F with a 3-minute rest. Use a meat thermometer in the center of a piece to check the temperature, because color is no proof. Reheat leftovers to 165°F (74°C).

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
The goat is still chewy when the potatoes are soft Tougher cut or older animal Lower the heat and keep simmering, checking with a fork, until the goat pulls apart
The broth tastes too salty The salt beef was soaked too briefly Add a little water and skip any extra salt. Next time give the salt beef its full overnight soak
The goat goes gray and watery instead of browning The oil was too cool or the pot was crowded Let the liquid cook off, then keep turning the pieces until they color
The aromatics scorch The heat stayed at browning level Lower the heat and stir. The tomatoes going in will lift the browned bits
Too hot to eat Habanero seeds left in, or a very hot chile Serve with funchi, rice or plain potatoes. Next time use part of the chile or seed it carefully

Serving, Variations and Leftovers

A bowl of cabrito stoba set on the table
Serve it in deep bowls so every spoonful gets broth along with the meat and potato

Ladle the stew into deep bowls, with plenty of the orange gravy over every portion. For an Aruban plate, add funchi and fried plantain, or keep it simple with rice. To drink, pour a cold lager or a Radler, or a soft red wine such as Malbec.

Variations

  • Lamb instead of goat. Swap it in for the goat cube for cube. The rest of the recipe stays the same.
  • Milder heat. Use half the habanero, or a gentler fresh chile. The tomato, lime and nutmeg come forward.
  • With pumpkin. One Aruban restaurant menu also lists cabrito stoba with fresh pumpkin. Pumpkin adds sweetness and softens into the gravy.

Leftovers

Cool the stew, then refrigerate it promptly in a covered container. Reheat it until it reaches 165°F (74°C) throughout and is steaming, stirring so the potatoes heat through as well.

Frequently asked questions

Why cook the salt beef on its own first?

The hour in plain water softens the beef and draws its salt and meaty flavor into the liquid. Strained, that liquid becomes the stock that finishes the stew. The salt beef seasons the whole pot twice, once as meat and once as broth.

Does goat taste strong?

Good goat is red and has little smell, and in this stew it tastes rich and hearty. The browning, the tomato and the lime all round it out. A strong smell is a sign of poor meat, so look for better goat rather than masking it.

Is this the same as the goat stew on Bonaire and Curaçao?

The three islands share the name and the love of goat stew, but each pot has its own ingredients. This is the Aruban version, with salt beef, annatto oil and potatoes. Cook the other islands' stews from their own recipes.

Can I use bone-in goat?

The recipe uses goat cut into ½-inch cubes, and those small pieces are what make the browning and simmering stages work. Pieces on the bone take longer to turn tender. Keep simmering them until the meat comes away from the bone, and check the temperature in the meat, away from the bone.

Sources