Pumpkin Scones: Australian Scones Baked with Mashed Pumpkin

Pumpkin scones just out of the oven, one split open with butter on the orange crumb
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Australian

Australia's pumpkin scones, likely born in Queensland: how to dry the steamed pumpkin, fold in self-raising flour with a light hand, and bake in a very hot oven.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Steam, dry and sieve the pumpkin

Cooked pumpkin being mashed with a fork in a bowl
Cooked pumpkin mashed in a bowl

Peel and cut the pumpkin, then steam it for about 15 minutes. Spread the pieces in a baking dish and dry them in a 390°F (200°C) oven for 10 minutes. Press the pumpkin through a sieve and measure out 1 cup of mash. Leave it to cool completely.

STEP22 / 6

Cream the butter, sugar and salt

Butter, sugar and salt creamed in a bowl with a wooden spoon
With so little butter, the mixture looks sandy rather than creamy

Put the butter, sugar and salt in a mixing bowl. Beat them in a mixer until they come together, or work them by hand with a wooden spoon. Stop when the mixture has come together.

STEP33 / 6

Beat in the egg, then the pumpkin

Egg and mashed pumpkin being stirred into the creamed mixture
Add the pumpkin only after the egg is fully mixed in

Add the egg and beat until it disappears into the creamed mixture. Then add the cold pumpkin mash and beat again. Keep going until the bowl holds an even orange batter with no streaks of egg or lumps of pumpkin.

STEP44 / 6

Fold in the flour by hand

Sifted flour being folded into the orange pumpkin mixture
A few uneven folds are all the dough needs

Tip the sifted self-raising flour onto the pumpkin mixture and fold it in by hand, turning the bowl as you go. Do not handle the mixture too much; stop as soon as no dry flour remains. Only if the pumpkin was very dry and the dough will not come together, add the 2 tbsp milk. The dough is right when it is soft and slightly sticky.

STEP55 / 6

Pat out and cut

Pumpkin dough on a floured bench with a round cutter pressed straight down
Flour on the cutter's edge stops it from dragging the soft dough

Turn the oven to 450°F (250°C) and give it time to heat fully. Turn the dough onto a lightly floured bench and pat it out about ¾ inch (2 cm) thick. Press the round cutter straight down without twisting and lift it clean. Gather the scraps together gently, pat them out again and cut more rounds.

STEP66 / 6

Bake in a very hot oven

Baked pumpkin scones with golden tops on the tray
Golden tops all across the tray mean the scones are ready to come out

Arrange the rounds on a greased or paper-lined baking tray. Bake in the very hot oven for 15–20 minutes. Lift the tray out with oven gloves and move the scones to a wire rack. They are done when the tops are risen and golden.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Butter 1 tbsp Flavour and tenderness
Sugar ½ cup Sweetness
Salt ¼ tsp Sharpens the flavour
Egg 1 Binds the dough
Mashed pumpkin, cooked and cooled 1 cup Flavour, moisture and colour
Self-raising flour, sifted 2 cups Structure and rise
Milk 2 tbsp, only if the pumpkin is very dry Loosens a dry dough
0 / 0

Split a pumpkin scone while it is still warm from the tray and the inside is orange, soft and faintly steaming, and a knob of butter slides straight into it. A pot of tea sits beside the plate, because that is where these belong. They are scones made with mashed pumpkin folded into a sweet, buttery dough, and they are one of Australia's best-known home bakes. The pumpkin gives them colour, a gentle sweetness and a tender crumb. Most of the skill lies in two things: how wet your pumpkin is, and how little you handle the dough.

A Queensland scone that went national

The pumpkin scone shares its method with the scones of Britain and Ireland: a quick dough, a round cutter, a hot oven, butter at the table. What sets it apart is the cup of mashed pumpkin and the noticeably sweet dough, which give it a softer, moister crumb and a colour no plain scone has. In Australia it is a fixture of afternoon tea, as much a part of the country's baking as anything else you will find on a page about Australian food.

Where it began

The scone is usually traced to Queensland, although where it was first made is not settled. The oldest known recipe is generally dated to 1912 and comes from Mitchell, a town in the state's south-west. By 1922 pumpkin scones had made it into an Australian cookbook. The early versions were close to what bakers make today, with flour, sugar, butter, milk, salt and pumpkin, raised with bicarbonate soda and cream of tartar, and sometimes bound with an egg.

What kept the recipe alive was the classroom. Pumpkin scones are recorded as part of Queensland's school home-economics teaching from 1936 to 1984, so generations of children learned to rub, fold and cut them at school before they ever baked them at home.

Lady Flo and the tea towels

From the late 1960s into the 1980s the scone had a second rise in fame, and it is tied to one person. Florence Bjelke-Petersen, known as Lady Flo, was the wife of Joh Bjelke-Petersen, Premier of Queensland from 1968 to 1987, and she later sat in the Senate herself from 1981 to 1993. Her pumpkin scones became famous across the country, and her recipe was printed on souvenir tea towels, two of which are now held in a library collection of Queensland textiles.

A recipe on a tea towel

A recipe printed on a tea towel has room for very little: the ingredients, the order of mixing, one warning about handling and the oven. That shortness is the point. It is a scone meant to be baked from memory.


Ingredients

The ingredients laid out: mashed pumpkin, self-raising flour, butter, sugar, salt, an egg and milk
The milk sits apart from the rest because it goes in only when the pumpkin is very dry
Allergen information

This recipe contains wheat (self-raising flour), egg and milk (butter, and milk if used).

Equipment

  • Steamer or a pot with a steaming basket
  • Baking dish for drying the pumpkin
  • Sieve, for the pumpkin and the flour
  • Electric mixer, or a mixing bowl and wooden spoon
  • Australian measuring cups and spoons
  • Round scone cutter, about 2¼ inches (5.5 cm)
  • Baking tray, greased or lined with baking paper
  • Wire rack

Choosing the pumpkin and the flour

The pumpkin decides the dough. Jarrahdale and Queensland blue are the pumpkins suited to these scones. Pumpkins differ in how much water they hold, and a wet mash makes a slack, sticky dough that spreads instead of rising. Whatever variety you buy, steam it, dry the pieces in the oven and then sieve it, and you control the moisture yourself instead of leaving it to the pumpkin.

Self-raising flour is worth seeking out. All of the rise in this dough comes from the raising agent already in the flour, and no other leavening is added. If your supermarket does not stock it, look in an import grocer or order it online. Plain flour on its own will give you flat, dense rounds.

The sugar is ordinary sugar, and unsalted butter keeps the ¼ tsp of salt in charge of the seasoning. Use whatever egg you have.

Dry pumpkin, not wet

Drying the steamed pumpkin in the oven before you sieve it is the move that most changes the result. A drier mash gives a dough you can pat out and cut cleanly, and it means you rarely reach for the milk.


Method

Cook the pumpkin first. It needs to be cold before it goes into the dough, so it is easiest to do this ahead, even the day before. After that the scones come together quickly: cream, add the egg and pumpkin, fold in the flour, cut, bake. Turn the oven up to full heat while you shape, because these go into a very hot oven.

Very hot oven

The oven runs at 450°F (250°C). Use dry oven gloves, open the door away from your face, and set the hot tray down on a heatproof surface.

Straight down, no twist

Twisting the cutter pinches the edges of the round shut, and a sealed edge rises unevenly. Push, lift, and move on to the next round.

When it goes wrong

What you see Why What to do
Dough is slack and sticks to everything The pumpkin mash was wet Pat it out on a well-floured bench and handle it with floured hands. Next time, dry the steamed pumpkin in the oven before sieving
Dough stays crumbly and will not come together The pumpkin was very dry Add the 2 tbsp milk and fold just until it holds
Scones are tough and heavy The dough was handled too much Fold the flour in only until no dry flour shows, and pat the dough out instead of kneading it
Rounds rise lopsided The cutter was twisted Press straight down and lift straight up
Batter looks streaky after the pumpkin goes in The egg was not fully beaten in first Beat the egg in completely before adding the pumpkin

Serving and making ahead

Pumpkin scones on a plate with butter, a teapot and cups, one broken in half
Breaking the scone by hand instead of cutting it keeps the crumb soft

Serve pumpkin scones with butter, either warm from the oven or once they have cooled to room temperature. Warm, the butter melts straight into the orange crumb. At room temperature the sweetness of the pumpkin comes through more. Put them out with a pot of tea, the way they turn up at Australian afternoon teas and kitchen tables.

The pumpkin is the part to do ahead. Steam, dry and sieve it, and chill it in the refrigerator; the next day it is already cold and ready for step 3.

Another pumpkin scone recipe uses icing sugar, an egg yolk instead of a whole egg, and a grating of nutmeg. That dough has a different balance, so make it as its own recipe rather than adding nutmeg to this one.

Frequently asked questions

Can I cook the pumpkin the day before?

Yes. Steam, dry and sieve it, then keep it in the refrigerator. Cold pumpkin is exactly what the dough wants, so you can start straight at the creaming step the next day.

What if I can only find plain flour?

Buy self-raising flour if you can, from an import grocer or online. The dough has no other raising agent, so its rise depends entirely on the flour. The earliest pumpkin scones were raised with bicarbonate soda and cream of tartar, but they are a different recipe from this one.

Can I make the dough in a food processor?

Cream the butter, sugar and salt, and beat in the egg and pumpkin, with a mixer or a spoon. Fold the flour in by hand. A machine overworks the dough in seconds, and overworked dough bakes tough.

Sources

  • State Library of Queensland, "Trusty Queensland CWA scone recipe hits sweet spot." Florence Bjelke-Petersen's pumpkin scone recipe as printed on two souvenir tea towels: ingredients, mixing order, light handling, milk only for very dry pumpkin, and baking at 250°C (450°F) for 15–20 minutes; also the dates of Joh Bjelke-Petersen's premiership and Florence Bjelke-Petersen's Senate term. https://www.slq.qld.gov.au/blog/trusty-queensland-cwa-scone-recipe-hits-sweet-spot
  • Gourmet Traveller, "Pumpkin scones." Pumpkin suited to scones (Jarrahdale, Queensland blue), steaming and oven-drying the pumpkin and sieving it, cooking it ahead and chilling, patting out to 2 cm and cutting straight down with a 5.5 cm cutter, and serving with butter warm or at room temperature. https://www.gourmettraveller.com.au/recipe/dessert/pumpkin-scones-8689/
  • Wikipedia, "Pumpkin scone." Likely Queensland origin, the earliest identified recipe of 1912 from Mitchell, the 1922 cookbook appearance, Queensland school home-economics teaching from 1936 to 1984, the revival from the late 1960s to the 1980s, and the ingredients of early recipes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumpkin_scone