Vanilla Slice: Australian Puff Pastry Slice with Thick Custard

A cut square of vanilla slice: two flat layers of golden puff pastry around thick pale-yellow custard, topped with passionfruit icing full of dark seeds
Serves
12 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Australian

Vanilla slice, the Australian bakery classic of thick custard between flat puff pastry. Learn the weighted bake, the two-minute boil and a clean cut.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Bake the pastry flat under a weight

A hand lowering a baking tray onto baking paper covering an unbaked puff pastry sheet
Leave both paper layers in place so the top tray lifts away cleanly after baking

Heat the oven to 355°F (180°C), or 320°F (160°C) fan-forced. Line two baking trays with baking paper and lay one thawed pastry sheet on each. Cover each sheet with another piece of baking paper, then set a second tray on top as a weight. Bake each sheet for about 20 minutes, until the pastry is golden and crisp right across.

STEP22 / 8

Cool the sheets, line the tin and trim

Two flat golden baked puff pastry sheets cooling on a wire rack
Look at the edges: thin, even layers with no puffed centre mean the weight did its job

Lift off the top trays and paper and cool the sheets on a wire rack. They should be thin and flat, with no domes. That flatness is the reason for the weight, because a flat sheet sits evenly on the custard. While they cool, line the square tin with two strips of baking paper laid across each other, each overhanging the sides by about ¾ inch (2 cm). Trim both sheets to fit the tin. Each one should fit snugly inside the paper.

The weight makes the slice

Do not skip the top tray. Unweighted puff pastry rises into uneven pillows, the custard pools in the dips, and the top sheet rocks when you cut. Flat sheets give the slice its straight layers.

STEP33 / 8

Warm the milk and cream

A saucepan of milk, cream, butter, vanilla bean paste and sugar warming on the stove
Fine vanilla specks spread through the liquid as the butter melts

Put the milk, cream, chopped custard butter, vanilla bean paste and caster sugar in a saucepan. Stir over medium heat as the butter melts and the sugar dissolves. Keep going until the mixture is steaming, with small bubbles trembling at the edge of the pan, just short of a boil. Take the pan off the heat.

STEP44 / 8

Whisk the yolks and cornstarch, then add the warm milk

Warm milk mixture poured in a thin stream into a bowl of egg yolks and cornstarch while whisking
Keep the stream thin and the whisk moving the whole time you pour

In a large bowl, whisk the cornstarch and egg yolks to a smooth, thick yellow paste with no dry starch left. Pour in the warm milk mixture a little at a time, whisking constantly. If you add it all at once, the yolks start to set into strands. When everything is in, the mixture should be smooth, loose and pale yellow, much thinner than custard.

STEP55 / 8

Boil the custard, then keep it boiling

A whisk stirring thick, glossy pale-yellow custard in a saucepan, with bubbles breaking the surface
Thick custard bubbles slowly and heavily. Keep the whisk moving so the base never catches

Pour the mixture back into the saucepan and set it over medium-high heat. Stir constantly, reaching into the corners of the pan, until it boils and thickens. Then keep it boiling and keep stirring for 2 more minutes. This is what lets the custard hold its shape later. After the 2 minutes the custard should be thick and glossy.

Rescuing lumps

If a few lumps form, push the custard through a sieve. If it is very lumpy, take the pan off the heat, blend the custard smooth with a hand blender, then put it back on the heat and finish the boil. A custard that has split or turned watery has been overcooked and cannot be brought back.

STEP66 / 8

Layer the slice and chill it

Hands placing the top baked pastry sheet onto warm custard in a paper-lined square tin
Lower the top sheet flat in one movement. A tilted sheet traps air and slides

Lay one pastry sheet in the lined tin. Pour the warm custard over it and spread it level to the corners. Set the second sheet on top and press down lightly so it sits flat against the custard. Put the tin in the fridge straight away and chill for about 4 hours, until the custard is firmly set and the tin is cold all through.

STEP77 / 8

Ice the chilled slice

A palette knife spreading seeded passionfruit icing over the top pastry of a chilled slice in its tin
Spread in long, even strokes. The seeds show you where the icing is too thin

Mix the icing sugar, melted icing butter and passionfruit pulp until smooth and spreadable, with the seeds spread evenly through it. Spread it over the top pastry of the chilled slice, out to the edges of the tin. Return the slice to the fridge for 30 minutes to set.

STEP88 / 8

Lift out and cut

A large knife cutting through a chilled vanilla slice on a board, showing pastry, custard and icing layers
Wipe the blade between cuts so icing does not drag across the next face

Lift the whole slice out of the tin by the paper overhangs and set it on a board. Cut it into squares or rectangles with a large knife, or a serrated knife if yours is small. Saw gently back and forth and never press straight down. The cut is right when each piece shows two straight pastry layers with the custard standing upright between them.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Frozen butter puff pastry sheets, thawed 2 sheets The flat, crisp top and bottom layers
Milk 1½ cups The base of the custard
Pure cream 1½ cups Richness and body in the custard
Unsalted butter, chopped (for the custard) 2 oz (60 g) A smooth, rich custard
Vanilla bean paste 2 tsp The vanilla aroma and the fine black seeds
Caster sugar ⅔ cup (160 ml) Sweetens the custard
Cornstarch (cornflour) ⅓ cup (80 ml) Thickens the custard so it sets
Egg yolks 6 Richness, colour and set
Icing sugar 1½ cups The body of the icing
Unsalted butter, melted (for the icing) ¾ oz (20 g) Gloss, and helps the icing spread
Passionfruit pulp 2½ tbsp (from about 2–3 passionfruit) Sharpness, perfume and the seeds
0 / 0

The custard decides everything. It boils in the pan, heavy and glossy, and you keep stirring after it already looks done while fat bubbles burst slowly through the surface. Hours later it comes out of the fridge as a tall, pale-yellow block between two thin sheets of crisp, flat puff pastry, under a passionfruit icing dotted with dark seeds. This is the vanilla slice from the counter of Australian bakeries. It is tall and hard to eat neatly. The yolks, cream and vanilla make the custard rich, the pastry shatters when you bite, and the tart icing cuts through the sweetness.

From mille-feuille to the snot block

Europe has a whole family of pastry-and-cream cakes: French mille-feuille, Polish kremówka, the Napoleon, kremšnita and krempita from the Balkans, and szegedinertorte. The vanilla slice clearly belongs to this family, but nobody has settled which of them it came from. The earliest relative usually mentioned is a gateau with frangipane in a French cookbook from 1651. Whatever its parent was, the Australian slice went its own way. A mille-feuille has a thin layer of custard. The Australian version has a thick one, so a slice stands tall on the plate, and every bite pushes the custard toward the edges.

Australian bakers judge a slice by that custard. They want it light and creamy, and they want it to hold when you bite into it. That is the standard this recipe aims for at home. The custard is thickened with cornstarch and egg yolks, boiled until it can stand up, and chilled firm before anyone picks up a knife.

A premier, a country town and a contest

In 1998 the Victorian premier, Jeff Kennett, praised a bakery in regional Victoria as the best in Australia. He called the vanilla slice "an important Australian culinary delicacy". That July he announced a competition, and on 23 October 1998 the first Great Australian Vanilla Slice Triumph was held in the town of Ouyen. Kennett stayed on as a judge until 2005. The contest later moved to Merbein and kept going, and at the 2016 event more than 18,000 slices were reported eaten. For a dish with no settled origin, it now has a firm place in Australia's food year. You can read more about the country's food on the Australia page.

The nicknames

Australians call it the snot block, the snot brick, phlegm cake and pus pie, all fondly. The nickname is thought to have started as local slang in central Victoria. It is a joke about the wobbling custard.


Ingredients (serves 12)

Thawed butter puff pastry sheets, milk, cream, chopped butter, vanilla bean paste, caster sugar, cornstarch, egg yolks, icing sugar, melted butter and passionfruit pulp
Set the two butters out apart: chopped for the custard, melted for the icing

The custard butter and the icing butter go in at different stages. Keep them in separate dishes so you never have to stop mid-method and work out how much to take.

Allergen information

This slice contains egg, milk and wheat (in the puff pastry). Check the pastry label for other allergens and for shared-facility statements.

Handling eggs

Use only clean eggs with no cracks. Do not wash eggs. Keep them in the fridge until you separate them. Raw or lightly cooked egg dishes should be avoided by older people, young children, pregnant people and anyone with weakened immunity. This custard is boiled, so give it the full boiling time, chill the slice promptly and keep it cold.

Equipment

  • 2 baking trays, plus a third tray or another flat, heavy tray to use as a weight
  • Baking paper
  • Wire rack
  • 8½-inch (22 cm) square cake tin
  • Medium saucepan
  • Large mixing bowl and a whisk
  • Fine sieve
  • Hand blender (for rescuing lumpy custard)
  • Palette knife or spatula
  • Large knife, or a serrated knife if your knife is small (an electric knife also works)

Choosing and substituting

Butter puff pastry is the one thing worth looking for. All-butter frozen sheets bake into crisp, savoury layers that stand up to the sweet custard. Pastry made with margarine or vegetable shortening tastes flatter and greasier. Sheet sizes vary between brands, which is fine, because you trim the baked sheets to fit the tin.

For the cream, buy real dairy cream and avoid "cream" made from vegetable fat, which gives the custard a duller, slightly waxy flavour. Caster sugar is superfine sugar. Ordinary fine granulated sugar dissolves in the warm milk just as well. Icing sugar is the same as powdered or confectioners' sugar.

Fresh passionfruit gives the brightest flavour and plenty of black seeds, which are part of how a vanilla slice looks. Frozen or jarred passionfruit pulp lets you make it all year. Check the label, because some pulps are strained and come without seeds. With those, the icing tastes right but looks plain.


Method

Allow about 45 minutes of hands-on work and 30 minutes of cooking, then a long, quiet stretch in the fridge. Bake and cool the pastry first, so it is ready and trimmed the moment the custard comes off the heat. The custard has to go into the tin warm. The only time you cannot walk away is while the custard is on the stove, so have the bowl, whisk and sieve within reach before you start.

A clean cut starts cold

Cut straight from the fridge. A slice that is fully chilled cuts cleanly, and one that has sat out softens and squeezes custard out under the knife. An electric knife does the sawing for you.

When it goes wrong

What you see Why What to do
Small lumps in the custard The yolks set unevenly or the base caught Push it through a sieve. For heavy lumps, blend off the heat with a hand blender, then reheat
Custard looks split or watery It was overcooked It cannot be fixed. Start a new batch and keep stirring over steady heat
The slice collapses or oozes when cut Not chilled long enough, or the custard did not boil for the full time Chill until firm. Next time, give the custard its full extra boil
Custard squeezes out under the knife The knife was pressed straight down Saw back and forth with a large or serrated knife, or use an electric knife
Pastry is domed and the top sheet rocks The pastry rose without a weight Bake under baking paper and a second tray so the sheets stay flat

Serving and variations

A rectangle of vanilla slice on a small plate with a fork, showing its layers
Serve cold, with a fork on the side

A vanilla slice belongs in the middle of the afternoon, next to a cup of tea or coffee, which cuts through the custard. Serve it cold from the fridge and hand out forks. The custard is soft, so most people end up using one.

Variations

  • Lemon icing. Swap the passionfruit for lemon juice in the icing. You get a plain, sharp citrus top with no seeds, and the slice tastes cleaner and less tropical.
  • Small café squares. Cut the slice into smaller pieces. They are easier to eat neatly, with more cut edges and a higher share of crisp pastry in each bite.
  • Frozen passionfruit pulp. Using frozen pulp lets you make the classic icing out of season. Choose a seeded pulp to keep the look.

Storage

The slice is best on the day it is made. Keep it covered in the fridge below 41°F (5°C) and finish it by the next day. Do not freeze it, because the custard separates as it thaws.

Frequently asked questions

Does vanilla slice need gelatine?

No. The custard sets from the cornstarch and egg yolks, boiled until thick and then chilled for hours. That is why the extra boil and the long chill matter so much. They do the work gelatine would do in other custard cakes.

Is cornflour the same as cornstarch?

In Australia, cornflour means cornstarch, the fine white starch made from corn, and that is what to buy. Do not reach for potato starch or other starches. The thickening and set of this custard are built on cornstarch.

Can I use vanilla extract instead of vanilla bean paste?

Yes. The custard still tastes of vanilla, but you lose the fine black seeds that show through the pale custard. Paste gives you both the aroma and the look, so it is worth buying if you make this slice often.

Sources