Pirão: Brazilian Fish Broth Thickened with Cassava Flour

Thick, pale orange-yellow pirão in a shallow white bowl, scattered with chopped parsley and chives and steaming, with white rice and a small dish of vinagrete beside it
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Brazilian

Pirão is the Brazilian fish-broth porridge thickened with cassava flour. Learn the cold-water slurry, the steady stir and the slow-drop spoon test.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Soak the fish heads and prep the vegetables

Three fish heads with the eyes removed, soaking in a stainless bowl of clear water
Keep the heads fully under the water for the whole soak

Remove the eyes from the fish heads. Put the heads in a bowl, cover them with water and leave them for 1 hour. While they soak, mince the garlic and onion, dice the tomatoes, and chop the parsley and chives. When the hour is up, discard the soaking water. The heads are ready and the vegetables sit in separate piles by the stove.

STEP22 / 7

Soften the garlic and onion

Chopped onion and garlic softening in olive oil with sweet paprika in a pot on a gas stove
Keep the onion pale and soft. Paprika burns quickly, so don't let the base brown

Heat a little olive oil in a large pot. Add the garlic and onion and stir them over the heat. Season with salt, black pepper and sweet paprika. They are done when the onion is translucent and soft and the oil has taken on the paprika's orange-red.

STEP33 / 7

Cook the tomato and break up the fish

Diced tomato and white fish being stirred until the fish flakes into the sofrito
Press any large piece against the side of the pot until it falls apart

Add the diced tomatoes and cook for about 2 minutes. Add the fish fillet and keep stirring with the wooden spoon, breaking it up as it cooks. Keep going until the fish has fallen apart into flakes and disappears into the red-orange base.

STEP44 / 7

Simmer the heads into a broth

Three fish heads submerged in gently simmering pale orange broth over a low flame
Keep it at a lazy simmer, with only small bubbles breaking at the surface

Pour in the water for simmering and bring it to a boil. Lower the heads into the pot, turn the heat to low and simmer for 20 minutes. Then lift the heads out and set them aside. What stays in the pot is a pale orange broth that smells clearly of fish, with the flaked fillet through it.

STEP55 / 7

Mix the flour with cold water

A spoon stirring cassava flour into cold water to make a milky mixture in a glass bowl
Small soft clumps break up with a few more turns of the spoon. Dry pockets do not

Put the cassava flour in a bowl. Pour in the cold water and stir until no dry flour is left. Scrape the bottom and sides of the bowl so nothing hides there. The mixture is ready when it is a pale, milky liquid that pours from the bowl.

Cold water, then a slow pour

Flour dropped dry into hot broth seizes into lumps at once. Mixed with cold water first, it spreads through the pot before it starts to thicken. Pour it in gradually, and stir all the while.

STEP66 / 7

Stir the flour into the broth

Hands stirring a thickening, glossy pale orange pirão with a wooden spoon
If you see a lump, press it against the side of the pot with the back of the spoon

Pour the flour mixture into the hot broth a little at a time, stirring with the wooden spoon as it goes in. Then keep stirring without stopping for about 15 minutes, working the spoon across the bottom and around the edges of the pot. The broth thickens, loses its raw floury look and turns smooth and glossy. Move on once the full time has passed and it coats the spoon thickly.

STEP77 / 7

Finish with lemon and herbs

Pirão falling slowly from a raised wooden spoon, with parsley and chives mixed in and a squeezed lemon beside the stove
The ribbon should fold back into the pot and sink in slowly, not hold a peak

Stir in the lemon juice, parsley and chives, then taste for salt and pepper. Lift the spoon and watch: the pirão should fall from the spoon slowly in a thick ribbon. If it is too thick, loosen it with a splash of hot broth. Stir in a thread of olive oil or a little butter for shine, and serve it hot.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
White fish fillet, such as tilapia (filé de peixe) 10½ oz (300 g) Flakes into the broth and carries the fish flavor
Fish heads (cabeça de peixe), eyes removed 3 Body and depth for the broth
Onion (cebola), medium 1 (3½ oz / 100 g) Sweetness
Garlic (alho), large cloves 3 Aroma
Tomatoes (tomate), large 2 (7 oz / 200 g) Acidity and color
Sweet paprika (páprica doce) to taste Color and a mild, sweet aroma
Water for simmering (água) 1½ cups + 1 tbsp (375 ml) The broth
Cassava flour, fine (farinha de mandioca) 3½ oz (100 g) Thickens the broth
Cold water for the flour about 1 cup (250 ml) Loosens the flour so it goes in without lumps
Lemon (limão) juice of ½ Freshens the fish flavor and adds sourness
Parsley (salsinha) and chives (cebolinha) to taste Fresh green finish
Salt (sal) and black pepper (pimenta-do-reino) to taste Seasoning
Olive oil (azeite) a little For the onion and garlic, and a drizzle to finish
Butter (optional) a little Gloss at the end, in place of the olive oil
0 / 0

The milky flour-and-water mixture goes into a pot of pale orange fish broth, and for a minute nothing seems to happen. Then the spoon starts to drag. The broth turns glossy and heavy, and by the end of the stirring it falls from the spoon in a slow, thick ribbon. That is pirão: fish broth, made from the heads as well as the fillet, thickened with cassava flour into a soft, spoonable porridge. It tastes of the sea, of sweet onion and tomato, with lemon and green herbs stirred through at the last moment. In Brazil it goes on the table beside the fish, the rice and the sharp tomato salsa, and everyone spoons a little onto their plate.

A Pot That Uses the Whole Fish

Pirão is built on getting everything out of a fish. The heads go into the broth with the fillet, the fillet is stirred until it falls apart, and the broth is not served as soup. Cassava flour is cooked into it until the whole pot turns into something you can put on a plate. What comes out has the depth of a long-cooked fish stock and the body of a porridge, and that is why a small spoonful sits so well next to a piece of fish and a mound of white rice.

It is a side dish, not the main event. On a Brazilian table pirão keeps company with fish stews such as moqueca, with white rice, with vinagrete (the chopped tomato-and-onion salsa) and with a bottle of homemade pepper sauce. It is filling, so the rest of the plate stays light: salad, vegetables, a little seasoned farofa. For more of the country's cooking, the Brazil page gathers the other dishes.

Region by region

The method changes as you move along the coast. In Bahia, pirão is made from the cooking liquid of the moqueca itself, so the side dish tastes like the stew it sits beside. In Ceará, cooks add coconut milk, colorífico and wheat flour. Inland and in the river country, freshwater fish such as pintado and tambaqui take the place of sea fish. Each household picks the fish it trusts, and everywhere the one rule is that the fish must be fresh.

Where it began

Cassava is older in Brazil than the Portuguese. Indigenous peoples grew it before the Portuguese arrived, and the newcomers learned from them how to use the root. Where pirão itself was first made is not settled. Some trace it to Indigenous cooking with cassava, others see a link to Africa, where very similar dishes are made.

Relatives across the Atlantic

Pirão is often set beside African dishes such as funge, fúngi and mfundi, which resemble it. Among these, pirão is the one built on fish broth and cassava flour.


Ingredients

Overhead view of a white fish fillet, three fish heads, onion, garlic, tomatoes, lemon, parsley, chives, paprika and cassava flour on a scale
Weigh the flour before you start. Once the stirring begins, your hands are on the spoon
Fine flour gives a smooth pirão

Buy fine farinha de mandioca. The finer the flour, the smoother and silkier the porridge. Coarse flour makes a grainier pot.

Allergen information

Contains fish. If you finish with butter, it contains milk. Use fresh fish and fish heads from a fishmonger you trust.

Equipment

  • Large pot
  • Wooden spoon
  • Bowl for soaking the fish heads
  • Bowl for mixing the flour with cold water
  • Knife and cutting board

Choosing the Fish and the Flour

The flour is the one thing worth a trip to a Brazilian or Latin American grocer, or an online order. Look for farinha de mandioca and read the description: Brazilian shops sell both a coarse, toasted cassava flour, the kind used for farofa, and a fine one. For pirão you want the fine one. Tapioca starch, the pure white powder sold for baking and bubble tea, is a different product, so keep it for other recipes.

Fish is easier. Brazilian cooks use grouper, hake, snook and tilapia from the sea and lagoons, and pintado or tambaqui from the rivers. At home, any mild, lean white fish does the job. Cod, sea bream and sea bass give a clean broth, and tilapia fillets are sold everywhere. Ask the fishmonger for heads from the same kind of fish (fish frames or "fish heads for stock"). Parsley and chives are easy to find, and so is sweet paprika. Make sure it is the sweet kind and not hot or smoked.


Method

Start with the fish heads, because they soak for an hour while you chop everything else. After that the work is short: a few minutes of frying, then a 20-minute simmer you can walk away from. The last part needs you at the stove. Once the flour goes in, you stir without stopping until the pirão is ready.

Judge it at the table, not in the pot

Pirão firms up as it cools. Serve it while it still flows slowly from the spoon, and it will be soft and spoonable on the plate.

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
Lumps in the pot The flour went in too fast, was not fully mixed with the cold water, or the stirring stopped Keep stirring hard and press lumps against the pot wall. Next time, mix the flour completely with cold water and pour slowly
Stiff, holds its shape Too much flour for the broth, or it has stood and cooled Loosen with hot broth, a splash at a time, until it falls slowly from the spoon again
Thin and soupy The stirring stopped before the flour had fully cooked into the broth Keep it on the heat and keep stirring for the full stirring time. It thickens as it goes
Strong fishy smell The fish or heads were not fresh enough Add the lemon juice and herbs. Next time, buy the freshest fish you can find
Dull and flat Too little salt, or no fat at the end Salt a pinch at a time, and stir in olive oil or butter just before serving

Serving, Variations and Storage

A table with a bowl of pirão, white rice, tomato-onion vinagrete and a pan-seared white fish fillet
Put the pirão beside the fish, not on top of it, so each forkful can take a little of both

Set pirão out in a bowl with white rice, vinagrete and fish, and pass the pepper sauce. Moqueca is the classic partner, but grilled or pan-seared white fish works just as well. Because pirão is rich and filling, the other sides stay light: a green salad, boiled vegetables, a spoonful of seasoned farofa.

Variations

  • From moqueca liquid (Bahia). Take about a glass of the moqueca cooking liquid. Add 2 tbsp tomato paste, cilantro and a glass of water, then add cassava flour a little at a time while stirring. The pirão takes its flavor from the stew's cooking liquid.
  • Coconut (Ceará). Coconut milk, colorífico and wheat flour go into the pot. This is the Ceará style.
  • Big batch with dendê. For about ten people, cook 10½ oz (300 g) fish in 2 quarts (2 L) water in a pressure cooker for 40 minutes, then strain. Whisk 9 oz (250 g) cassava flour gradually into the broth while it is still cold. Bring it to a boil over medium heat and cook for 10–15 minutes more. This version adds 6 tbsp dendê oil, colorau and a shrimp bouillon cube, and you can use olive oil in place of the dendê.

Storage

Pirão is best on the day it is made. Cool leftovers, then refrigerate them promptly in a covered container and eat them soon. Reheat until steaming hot all the way through, loosening the pirão with a little hot water or broth as it warms.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use tapioca starch instead of cassava flour?

Use farinha de mandioca, the flour this recipe is written for. Tapioca starch is a different product, so do not treat the two as interchangeable.

How is pirão different from farofa?

Both are made from cassava flour. Farofa uses the coarse, toasted flour, fried with fat and seasonings and served dry and crumbly. Pirão uses the flour as a thickener, cooked into fish broth until it turns to soft porridge. They often share a table.

Can I make the broth in a pressure cooker?

Yes. For the large batch, cook the fish in the pressure cooker, strain the broth, whisk the flour into it while it is cold, and then bring it to a boil. The pressure cooker saves time on the broth. The thickening still happens in an open pot, with the spoon in your hand.

Sources