Worcestershire Sauce: Aged English Anchovy, Tamarind and Vinegar Sauce

A few drops of deep brown homemade Worcestershire sauce on a small saucer, with a sealed jar beside it in a home kitchen
Serves
About 3 cups
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
British

Homemade Worcestershire sauce from Worcester, England: anchovy, tamarind, molasses and vinegar blended, boiled once, aged a month in the fridge, strained.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Soak the raisins and prepare the aromatics

A small bowl of raisins soaking in hot water next to partly chopped onion, ginger and crushed garlic
Rough pieces are fine because the processor does the fine work. Crushing the garlic opens it up so it blends smoothly

Put the raisins in a heatproof bowl and pour the boiling water over them. Leave them for 15 minutes. Meanwhile, coarsely chop the onion, peel and chop the ginger, and crush the garlic cloves flat with the side of a knife. Drain the raisins and throw away the soaking water. The raisins are ready when they look plump and give easily under your finger, and the onion and ginger should be in rough pieces that fit in the food processor.

STEP22 / 5

Blend everything into a smooth paste

A food processor bowl holding a smooth dark brown paste
A few tiny flecks of raisin skin are fine. Large pieces of onion mean it needs more blending

Put the drained raisins, molasses, tamarind paste, the anchovies with all their oil, onion, ginger, garlic and 1 cup (240 ml) of the vinegar into the food processor. Blend until smooth, stopping once or twice to scrape down the sides. The fish and onion pieces should disappear completely. The paste is ready when it is thick, dark brown and free of grit.

STEP33 / 5

Add the spices and bring it to the boil once

Brown sauce coming to the boil in a saucepan, with whole cloves and cardamom on the surface
Watch the edges. When the bubbles spread from the rim across the middle, take the pan off the heat

Scrape the paste into the saucepan and add the remaining 1 cup (240 ml) of vinegar. Add the cardamom, salt, brown sugar, red pepper flakes, dry mustard, cloves, peppercorns and cinnamon, and stir well. Set the pan over medium-high heat. As soon as the whole surface is bubbling, take the pan off the heat.

Boil once, then stop

This sauce is never reduced. Bringing it to the boil and taking it off the heat right away keeps the molasses and sugar from catching and turning bitter. The spices release their flavour during the weeks of aging, not in the pan.

Hot vinegar

Boiling vinegar gives off sharp steam. Keep your face away from the pan when you lean over it, and use a ladle and funnel when you fill the jar so the hot sauce does not splash.

STEP44 / 5

Fill the jar and put it in the refrigerator to age

A quart jar filled with deep brown sauce being closed with a plastic lid
The level sits just below the rim. A plastic lid stays clean where vinegar would eat into metal

Let the sauce cool slightly in the pan. Ladle it through the funnel into the clean 1-quart jar, whole spices and all, and fill it right up to the neck so there is no empty gap above the sauce. Close it with a plastic lid, then put the jar in the refrigerator and leave it there for at least one month. The jar is ready when the sauce reaches the neck, the lid is tight, and no metal touches the sauce.

Use a plastic lid

Vinegar corrodes metal lids, so seal the jar with plastic only, both now and after straining. Use canned anchovies and never raw fish.

STEP55 / 5

Strain after a month or more

Aged sauce being poured through a fine-mesh strainer, with solids left in the mesh and clear brown liquid below
Raisin skins, onion and ginger stay in the strainer. The sauce underneath should be smooth with no sediment

After at least a month, open the jar and check it before you do anything else. If it smells off, has a white film on top or is fizzing with gas, throw the whole jar away without straining. If it looks and smells right, pour it through the fine-mesh strainer into a bowl, leaving the solids in the mesh, then pour the strained sauce into a clean jar with a plastic lid. It is done when the liquid is deep brown, slightly thick and strongly aromatic.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Raisins ¼ cup (60 ml) Sweetness and body. Soaked, then blended in
Boiling water ¼ cup (60 ml) For soaking the raisins. Throw it away afterwards
Unsulfured molasses ½ cup (120 ml) Dark colour, deep sweetness, richness
Tamarind paste ¼ cup (60 ml) Fruity sourness
Anchovies in oil 1 can (2 oz / 57 g), with its oil The savoury backbone of the sauce
Onion 1 large, coarsely chopped Sweetness and depth
Fresh ginger 1-inch (2.5 cm) piece, peeled and chopped Warm aroma
Garlic 6–8 cloves, crushed Aroma
White vinegar (5% acidity) 2 cups (480 ml), divided Sourness and keeping quality. 1 cup goes into the food processor, 1 cup into the pan
Whole cardamom 2 pods Fragrance
Kosher or canning salt 2 tbsp (30 ml) Saltiness and keeping quality
Brown sugar 2 tbsp (30 ml) Sweetness, deeper colour
Crushed red pepper flakes 1 tbsp (15 ml) Heat
Dry mustard 1 tbsp (15 ml) Pungency and aroma
Whole cloves 1 tsp (5 ml) Aroma. Keep them whole
Black peppercorns 1 tsp (5 ml) Aroma. Keep them whole
Ground cinnamon ½ tsp (2.5 ml) A soft, sweet spice note
0 / 0

When the brown paste in the saucepan reaches the boil, the vinegar steam hits sharply, and clove, black pepper and mustard come up with it. That boil is the only cooking the sauce gets. After that it goes into a jar and waits in the dark of the refrigerator for a month or longer. When you strain it, the sauce has turned dark and pourable. It tastes sour and salty first, then sweet, with a deep savoury note from the anchovies that you notice without being able to name it. Worcestershire sauce comes from the English city of Worcester, and a few drops are enough to change a whole plate.

From a Worcester Pharmacy to Tables Overseas

The sauce goes back to 1837. That year two chemists, Lea and Perrins, started making it at their pharmacy at 68 Broad Street in Worcester. Nobody knows exactly when they first sold it. The bottle is now so familiar that people forget it began as a mixture made up behind a chemist's counter in Worcester. You can find more of the country's cooking on our United Kingdom page.

It reached distant markets fast. On 19 September 1846 the Maitland Mercury, a newspaper in New South Wales, ran an advertisement for "Celebrated Worcester Sauce, Patronized by the Royal Family." That is the earliest known advertisement for the sauce in Australia. It went there as an imported English condiment, not as part of Australian cooking. Back in Worcester, production moved to a new factory on Midland Road in 1896, though some accounts give the year as 1897.

The ingredients have always been partly secret. Anchovies and vinegar were known to matter. Until the Second World War, soy sauce was one of the main hidden ingredients. A homemade version printed in an American magazine in 1873 already used soy sauce, so people were trying to copy the bottle at home within a few decades. The factory sauce was aged in casks in the cellars before bottling, and the month of rest in the refrigerator here follows the same idea.

Bottled sauces still vary, and the vinegar is one of the differences. The type used changes from product to product, so two brands can taste quite different. This homemade version uses anchovies and tamarind, as British and American home versions do. White vinegar and a month or more of rest in the cold do the rest.

From pharmacy to factory

The sauce started in a chemist's shop on Broad Street in 1837. It later moved into its own factory on Midland Road.


Ingredients (makes about 3 cups)

Raisins, molasses, tamarind, a tin of anchovies, onion, ginger, garlic, vinegar and spices laid out together
Everything goes in within the first three steps, so set it all out before you start

One tablespoon of the finished sauce is one serving, so a single jar lasts a long time.

Use the anchovy oil too

Tip the whole can into the food processor, oil included. The oil carries much of the fish flavour, and it is what gives the finished sauce its savoury depth.

Allergen information

This sauce contains fish (anchovies), plus mustard, onion, garlic and several whole spices. It has no dairy, and none of the listed ingredients contain gluten, but check the labels on the anchovy can, tamarind paste and molasses. If you cannot eat onion or garlic, use a little asafoetida in their place.

Equipment

  • Small food processor or blender
  • Heatproof bowl and a small sieve for the raisins
  • Medium saucepan
  • Ladle and funnel
  • A clean 1-quart (0.95 L) glass jar with a plastic lid
  • Fine-mesh strainer and a second clean jar with a plastic lid
  • Knife, cutting board, measuring cups and spoons

Choosing and Substituting

Three things are worth a trip to a specialty grocer or an order online. Tamarind paste supplies the fruity sourness. It is the same sour fruit that seasons pad thai. Unsulfured molasses gives the dark colour and deep sweetness. Whole cardamom pods add a high, floral note. Everything else is ordinary supermarket shopping.

Check the vinegar label for 5% acidity. Plain white vinegar usually meets it. If you use rice vinegar or wine vinegar, read the label, because the acidity changes from bottle to bottle. Salt comes in different grain sizes, so measure kosher or canning salt by volume. If you only have table salt or flaky sea salt, add it gradually and taste instead of swapping spoon for spoon.

For the sugar, this version uses brown sugar rather than maple syrup. Brown sugar makes the flavour fuller and the colour darker, which suits a sauce that is meant to be almost black. Maple syrup works in the same amount and tastes a little lighter.

Ingredient Keep it, or let it go? What changes
Canned anchovies with oil Keep Without them the savoury depth is gone. Dried anchovies work once soaked in hot water
5% white vinegar Keep Sourness and keeping quality both depend on it
A month or more of aging Keep The aroma builds only with time
Molasses Swap if needed Dark brown sugar can stand in. The flavour shifts
Raisins Swap if needed A little brown sugar can replace them. The fruit note gets weaker
Tamarind paste Can be left out The sauce turns less sour and less fruity
Whole cardamom Can be left out The fragrance gets softer

Method

Start the raisins first and do the chopping while they soak. The blending and the single boil go quickly, so measure the spices and set out a clean jar before you turn on the heat. After that the sauce needs no work at all. It sits in the refrigerator for at least a month, and then you strain it.

Judge the aging by smell

A month is the minimum. The longer the sauce rests, the stronger its aroma gets, and three months gives a fuller result. If the sauce smells mostly of raw vinegar when you open it, close the jar and give it more time before straining.

When It Goes Wrong

What you see Why What to do
The paste is grainy or has visible onion pieces It was not blended long enough Blend again before it goes into the pan. Grit stays in the sauce and leaves more solids to strain out
The sauce tastes bitter or scorched It boiled too long and the molasses and sugar caught Next time take it off the heat as soon as the surface bubbles all over. The sauce is never reduced
The aroma is thin and the vinegar tastes raw It aged for less than a month Seal it again and leave it longer in the refrigerator. The aroma gets stronger with time
The flavour is flat after straining It needs more brightness Stir in a splash more vinegar. It sharpens the sauce more than extra salt does
An off smell, white film or gas in the jar The sauce has spoiled Throw it away without straining or tasting
The lid is rusted or pitted Vinegar has corroded a metal lid Use a plastic lid only

Serving, Variations and Storage

A few drops of homemade Worcestershire sauce spooned over a pan-seared pork chop with sliced potatoes
A few drops are enough. Put the sauce on at the table so its aroma stays sharp

At the table

One tablespoon is a serving, and you rarely need more. Spoon a few drops over a pan-seared pork chop and potatoes, or set the jar beside a plate of bangers and mash so everyone can add their own. Its vinegar edge also works with fried food, the same way vinegar is shaken over fish and chips.

Variations

  • Less anchovy, or none. The savoury depth drops, and the sweetness and sourness come forward.
  • Less red pepper. The heat goes down, and the spice aroma also feels lighter.
  • No tamarind. The sauce is less sour and less fruity, and the molasses takes over.
  • Two or three months of aging. Every extra month makes the aroma stronger and rounder.

Storage

Keep the strained sauce in the refrigerator in its clean jar with a plastic lid, and put it back after each use. The salt and 5% vinegar help preserve it, but this recipe is not meant for room-temperature canning, so it belongs in the cold for its whole life. If you cut the salt or vinegar, refrigeration matters even more. Before each use, check for an off smell, film or fizzing, and throw the sauce away if you find any.

Frequently asked questions

Will it taste like the bottled sauce?

No. The commercial formulas are secret, and this is a homemade sauce with its own balance. It has the same sour, sweet and savoury structure, with a fruit note from the raisins and tamarind.

Do I need to water-bath can the jars?

No. The sauce is aged, not fermented, and it does not go through a canning step. It stays in the refrigerator, from the month of aging through to the last spoonful.

Can I use fresh anchovies?

No, fresh anchovies cannot replace the canned ones. Use anchovies canned in oil and add the oil with them. Dried anchovies also work if you soak them in hot water first.

What can I do with the strained solids?

Stir them into a soup for a savoury boost. You can also dry them and grind them into a powder to use as a seasoning.


Sources

  • Soyinfo Center, "History of Worcestershire Sauce (1837-2012)." The start of production in 1837 by the chemists Lea and Perrins at 68 Broad Street, Worcester. The 1846 Maitland Mercury advertisement in New South Wales. The Midland Road factory. The 1873 homemade version with soy sauce. Cellar aging in casks. Anchovies, vinegar and soy sauce as key ingredients. https://www.soyinfocenter.com/books/152
  • Ashley Adamant, "Homemade Worcestershire Sauce," Practical Self Reliance. Ingredients, amounts and method. Yield of about 3 cups and the one-tablespoon serving. Aging for at least a month, with three months for a fuller result. Plastic lids. Canned and dried anchovies. Asafoetida for allium intolerance. Use of the strained solids. https://practicalselfreliance.com/homemade-worcestershire-sauce/
  • University of Illinois Extension, "5% acidity vinegar is key to safe canning." Vinegar of 5% acidity as the standard behind safe home-canned foods, and the reason this sauce is kept refrigerated. https://extension.illinois.edu/news-releases/5-acidity-vinegar-key-safe-canning